Thanks. Well said. You're right. I agree.

afan

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Svensson, B.A.T. (HKG) 
  To: Afan Pasalic ; [EMAIL PROTECTED] 
  Sent: Tuesday, August 20, 2002 1:54 PM
  Subject: RE: [PHP-WIN] resolution?


  Afan:

  my point is this: let the decision making process be handled
  by the human and not the machine. Machines are simply not
  smart enough - yet - to handles these kind of decisions,
  since what you tries to do is to interpret the users
  intention.

  The decision you're trying to make automatically in
  this case is to figure out the users true intention.

  Trying to perceive another humans intention is even a
  hard task for a human, not mentioningthe numerous
  problem trying to make a machine do the very same thing.
  This limitation might exists because the machine is not
  able to perform a conscious introperspection [spell check?]
  and thus can't even understand what it even means to have an
  intention.

  That's why you should avoid doing it automagical.

  In particular do not expand windows to max size or other
  envirionment changes without asking the user about it first:
  it will only frustrate a user if he feels that the program is
  in control and he is not. 

  In general: never force an option onto a user if there
  exists several option: let the user deiced first, and
  then execute the request.

  As human we don't want to be pushed around, but like to feel
  that we do have control of the direct surrounding, and preferable
  a little bit more (some even becomes politician to achieve the
  "little bit more" part).

Reply via email to