If you can use virtual private network, it is secure. But I don't know 
about plain Samba solution.

Chris Hewitt wrote:

> Marek,
>
> Yes I thought about windows shares. On the internet (as opposed to 
> intranet) the word "security" leapt to mind and I went away from the 
> idea. Has anyone used Samba shares on the internet or know if its 
> secure/insecure?
>
> Thanks
>
> Chris
>
> Marek Kilimajer wrote:
>
>> The only way I see this can be done is simly let every user mount a 
>> share under the same letter,
>> all you need to do then is <a 
>> href="file:///X:/directory/file.doc">file</a>, then locking files is up
>> to samba or windows server.
>>
>>    Marek
>>
>> Richard Lynch wrote:
>>
>>>> I have an intranet, which provides access to, amongst others, Word 
>>>> Documents about policies, etc. What the guys are looking for is a 
>>>> way to do the following:
>>>>
>>>> 1. Show a list of files available for editing
>>>> 2. If a file is clicked, then it is locked for other users (no access)
>>>> 3. The file opens on the client's machine
>>>> 4. The client edits it
>>>> 5. The client then closes the file, it "auto-saves" and he goes 
>>>> about his business.
>>>>
>>>> Points 1 through 3 are relatively trivial. Point 4 and 5 
>>>> (especially 5) have me lost.
>>>>
>>>> How do you get a file to be edited, and then automatically returned 
>>>> to the server by M$ Word in it's changed format. Is this possible?
>>>>
>>>> How would this change in a database-backended system (including the 
>>>> files as BLOBs)?
>>>>   
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> They'd have to be "uploaded" *SOMEHOW*...
>>>
>>> If the employees can't do that "by hand", then perhaps some kind of
>>> "scheduled" task on the Win boxes could be programmed to do it.
>>>
>>> Don't forget to *UNLOCK* after a successful upload, but not when, 
>>> not if,
>>> when, the upload fails.
>>>
>>> There's simply NO WAY the server can reach out and suck in a file of 
>>> its own
>>> volitoin... Major privacy/security problem there.
>>>
>>> You *COULD* also install Apache + PHP on every desktop, and have them
>>> serving up their edited Word files to the Intranet, and then PHP 
>>> could use
>>> HTTP to suck them back in...
>>>
>>> But that's probably not gonna fly for non-technical reasons.  Well, not
>>> counting really bad Security as a "technical" reason.
>>>
>>>  
>>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>



-- 
PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Reply via email to