"
Aready done. Look for Jan Vrany tools or Cuis. IMHO, not convincing to me
(Jan's format is even more conflict-oriented than Filetree metadata, but it
is a design goal). Cuis git repository is a mess to me; very hard to build
a coherent 'rebuild a new Cuis here' process on it like I routinely do on
Pharo."


Cuis I downloaded it, does not seem to have such a tool, talking about auto
export of code.

Jon Vrany which I found here

https://github.com/janvrany?tab=overview&from=2015-12-01&to=2015-12-31&utf8=✓

appears that he has not done any Smalltalk coding for more than a year and
I could not find one repo that has such tool.

Just to make it clear what I am proposing here is not just a replacement
for filetree but I complete bypass of Monticello. I have been a frequent
visitor of the pharo mailing lists for more than 5 years not I never head
of such a thing. It is also the first time I mention this idea as well. I
had in my mind for so long but it has been a low priority because filetree
worked without any issues other than browsing the code in code editor and
online Github.

"I've seen over the years many, many attempts at replacing the filetree
format. I used to contest and debate, now I just let them go and die a few
months later. Because none of the alternatives are clearly superior, and it
is not worth the effort to reimplement."

Well if by dying you mean none else but me will use it, most certainly you
are correct. But all my projects are foremost personal I never make
something for public consumption other than offering a helping hand with
Pharo documentation.

I am perfectly ok with the fact that people do not use my projects.

And foremost its not as if a tool that would bypass monticello and filetree
and gitfiletree and iceberg has any chance to be used when for months now
the mailing list has been talking about Iceberg.

Its clear that I want to live outside the image.

Its clear that others want to live inside the image.

Its clear that I am a tiny minority , if not the only one.


>

Reply via email to