"Because this two productions define a list of stmt (possibly empty) and
the AST generation code notices that, so it adds an s to statement and
prepare that instance variable to be an OrderedCollection."

yes but I find it a bit misleading because even when there is a single
element it still going to create an OrderedCollection and still add "s" to
the name of the variable.

By they way I have been successful into implementing , with your help, a
parser that parses python lists into pharo ordered collections. Python
tuples and dictionaries are next. Have not implemented nesting types but
that is very close too.

Took me a lot of time to understand the syntax of SmaCC and moreover to be
able to understand the grammar used for the PythonParser2. I decided not to
change the grammar since it can do what I want as it is and augment any
additional parsing with my own classes.

Now I understand the meaning of tests, PyAtomNode and more importantly
PyPowerNode.

My overall experience with Smacc has been quite positive , the
documentation is in a good state though I would like more practical
examples especially on the matter of visitor. I love the Smacc syntax, its
compact , readable and fairly easy to understand. I really like the design
of the classes , make sense and are predictable.

A final question is how up to date in the configuration loaded with
configuration browser.

The only thing I really missed from Smacc is a specialised to help me
browse the huge python grammar. Scrolling around became very tedious .

Reply via email to