Hi Amit-san!

Thanks for your comments!


I have looked at the patch and here are some comments.

I think include_children and current_relid are not enough to
understand the progress of analyzing inheritance trees, because even
with current_relid being updated, I can't tell how many more there
will be.  I think it'd be better to show the total number of children
and the number of children processed, just like
pg_stat_progress_create_index does for partitions.  So, instead of
include_children and current_relid, I think it's better to have
child_tables_total, child_tables_done, and current_child_relid, placed
last in the set of columns.

Ah, I understood.
I'll check pg_stat_progress_create_index does for partitions,
and will create a new patch. :)

Related to the above,
I wonder whether we need the total number of ext stats on
pg_stat_progress_analyze or not. As you might know, there is the same
counter on pg_stat_progress_vacuum and pg_stat_progress_cluster.
For example, index_vacuum_count and index_rebuild_count.
Would it be added to the total number column to these views? :)


Also, inheritance tree stats are created *after* creating single table
stats, so I think that it would be better to have a distinct phase
name for that, say "acquiring inherited sample rows".  In
do_analyze_rel(), you can select which of two phases to set based on
whether inh is true or not.  For partitioned tables, the progress
output will immediately switch to this phase, because partitioned
table itself is empty so there's nothing to do in the "acquiring
sample rows" phase.

That's all for now.


Okay! I'll also add the new phase "acquiring inherited sample rows" on
the next patch. :)


Thanks,
Tatsuro Yamada



Reply via email to