On Tue, 19 Feb 2019 at 12:15, Tom Lane <t...@sss.pgh.pa.us> wrote: > Now that I've looked at *this* thread's patch, I agree that having > the executor acquire locks based on find_all_inheritors() is a > pretty horrid idea. However, it still seems like this is being > done in a vacuum without attention to locks already acquired > upstream. How much does the knowledge that the planner or plancache > would've already locked everything mentioned in the rangetable > affect the issues here?
For the INSERT with VALUES case, there should be no existing locks on the partition. Only the partitioned table that's the target of the INSERT will have been locked already. For the INSERT with SELECT case, well, it's possible that one of the partitions exist in the SELECT and it was already locked by the planner or in AcquireExecutorLocks(), but how is that different from having multiple RangeTblEntry objects for the same relation? We already try to lock those twice. If we had code to resolve those duplicates and take just the strongest of the locks for the relation then I might feel we'd better handle the locking better in this patch, but we don't, so I see no reason to add additional smarts for a corner case if we have none for a more common case. For the UPDATE case, we reuse result relations from the ModifyTable's subnodes. See ExecFindPartition() around: /* * We have not yet set up a ResultRelInfo for this partition, * but if we have a subplan hash table, we might have one * there. If not, we'll have to create one. */ if (proute->subplan_resultrel_htab) > I'm inclined to think that if we already have lock on the parent > partitioned table (thereby, IIUC, guaranteeing that its partitioning > info can't change) that the order in which we acquire the same lock > level on its partition(s) isn't very important. Yeah. I think most people seem to agree with that too. At least, nobody seemed to raise any concerns about increased deadlock risk, although it was talked about. -- David Rowley http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/ PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Training & Services
