On 2019-Jan-16, Michael Paquier wrote: > Regarding the grammar, we tend for the last couple of years to avoid > complicating the main grammar and move on to parenthesized grammars > (see VACUUM, ANALYZE, EXPLAIN, etc). So in the same vein I think that > it would make sense to only support CONCURRENTLY within parenthesis > and just plugin that with the VERBOSE option.
That's my opinion too, but I was outvoted in another subthread -- see https://postgr.es/m/20181214144529.wvmjwmy7wxgmgyb3@alvherre.pgsql Stephen Frost, Andrew Gierth and Andres Freund all voted to put CONCURRENTLY outside the parens. It seems we now have three votes to put it *in* the parens (you, Peter Eisentraut, me). I guess more votes are needed to settle this issue. My opinion is that if we had had parenthesized options lists back when CREATE INDEX CONCURRENTLY was invented, we would have put it there. But we were young and needed the money ... -- Álvaro Herrera https://www.2ndQuadrant.com/ PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Remote DBA, Training & Services
