While working on the thread 'Rollback on include error in psql' I ran across 
something I am not sure with regards to ON_ERROR_ROLLBACK:

aklaver@panda:~> psql -d test -U aklaver -p 5452 --single-transaction  --set 
ON_ERROR_STOP=on --set AUTOCOMMIT=off -f test_script.sql 
UPDATE 1
psql:test_script.sql:2: some_missing_file.sql: No such file or directory


aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:32.443 PST-0LOG:  statement: BEGIN
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:32.443 PST-0LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET col = 
'some other value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:32.444 PST-129436LOG:  statement: COMMIT

aklaver@panda:~> psql -d test -U aklaver -p 5452  --single-transaction --set 
ON_ERROR_ROLLBACK=1 --set AUTOCOMMIT=off -f test_script.sql 
UPDATE 1
psql:test_script.sql:2: some_missing_file.sql: No such file or directory
UPDATE 1

aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.656 PST-0LOG:  statement: BEGIN
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.657 PST-0LOG:  statement: SAVEPOINT 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.657 PST-0LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET col = 
'some other value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.658 PST-129437LOG:  statement: RELEASE 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.658 PST-129437LOG:  statement: SAVEPOINT 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.658 PST-129437LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET 
col = 'yet another value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.659 PST-129437LOG:  statement: RELEASE 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:44:42.659 PST-129437LOG:  statement: COMMIT

aklaver@panda:~> psql -d test -U aklaver -p 5452  --single-transaction --set 
ON_ERROR_ROLLBACK=0 --set AUTOCOMMIT=off -f test_script.sql 
UPDATE 1
psql:test_script.sql:2: some_missing_file.sql: No such file or directory
UPDATE 1

aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.113 PST-0LOG:  statement: BEGIN
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.114 PST-0LOG:  statement: SAVEPOINT 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.114 PST-0LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET col = 
'some other value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.115 PST-129440LOG:  statement: RELEASE 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.115 PST-129440LOG:  statement: SAVEPOINT 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.115 PST-129440LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET 
col = 'yet another value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.116 PST-129440LOG:  statement: RELEASE 
pg_psql_temporary_savepoint
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:23.116 PST-129440LOG:  statement: COMMIT


aklaver@panda:~> psql -d test -U aklaver -p 5452  --single-transaction --set 
ON_ERROR_ROLLBACK=off --set AUTOCOMMIT=off -f test_script.sql 
UPDATE 1
psql:test_script.sql:2: some_missing_file.sql: No such file or directory
UPDATE 1

aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:57.344 PST-0LOG:  statement: BEGIN
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:57.345 PST-0LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET col = 
'some other value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:57.346 PST-129443LOG:  statement: UPDATE testtbl SET 
col = 'yet another value';
aklaver-2014-12-29 08:46:57.346 PST-129443LOG:  statement: COMMIT


So it seems you can turn ON_ERROR_ROLLBACK on with either 1 or 'on', but you 
can only turn it off with 'off'.
With ON_ERROR_STOP 1/on and 0/off both seem to work. 

Is this expected?

-- 
Adrian Klaver
adrian.kla...@aklaver.com


-- 
Sent via pgsql-general mailing list (pgsql-general@postgresql.org)
To make changes to your subscription:
http://www.postgresql.org/mailpref/pgsql-general

Reply via email to