This and other RFCs are available on the web at
http://dev.perl.org/rfc/
=head1 TITLE
Handlers and Pseudo-classes
=head1 VERSION
Maintainer: Nathan Wiger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: 14 Aug 2000
Last Modified: 12 Sep 2000
Mailing List: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Number: 101
Version: 2
Status: Developing
=head1 CHANGES
1. Clarified a few points
2. Wrote a Perl 5 implementation
=head1 ABSTRACT
A complete Perl 5 implementation of this can be found as Class::Handler
http://www.perl.com/CPAN/authors/id/N/NW/NWIGER/Class-Handler-1.03.tar.gz
Currently, there is no way to have multiple methods or modules for
dealing with events without significant contortions:
$data = $r1->get_data || $r2->stuff || $r3->func;
$r1->do_stuff(@vals) or $r1->do_this(@vals);
These simple cases can actually be tolerated. However, there are many
more complex cases which cannot be handled at all in Perl. These include
opening files only in certain directories, having methods decline or
partially handle requests, and so on.
This RFC proposes the idea of a C<handler>, which is a special type of
class that is actually composed of one or more classes. Their operation
is very similar to Apache handlers: requests can be handled, declined,
or partially handled, without the top-level program having to know about
it.
=head1 DESCRIPTION
=head2 Overview
The concept of a C<handler> is actually not that complex. In the
simplest case, it can be thought of as a type of abstraction:
sub open_it {
my $file = shift;
return open $file ||
HTTP::open $file ||
FTP::open $file;
}
Then, in your script, you would simply say:
$fileobject = open_it "< $filename";
This gives you several benefits:
1. The internal handling of open_it can be changed
without having to update all your programs
2. Each operation can actually partially process
the request, if appropriate
2. Your program is easier to read and understand
>From a Perl standpoint, these handlers work just like normal functions
and classes: they have methods, properties, inheritance, and so forth.
The only difference is that these handlers do not live in an external
file, but rather are assembled internally by Perl.
=head2 Adding and Using Handlers
First, the examples assume that the reader is somewhat familiar with RFC
14. If not, it is recommended that you give it a quick read at
http://dev.perl.org/rfc/14.pod
There are several competing syntaxes that I have for this proposal. I've
provided the one that I think is the best, but this is open to
discussion.
The proposed syntax is to use a pragmatic style:
use handler 'http' => 'MyHTTP';
use handler 'http' => 'LWP::UserAgent';
This would assemble a C<handler> called 'http' which could then be used
in functions in your program. This handler would be a pseudo-class that
inherits methods from C<MyHTTP> and C<LWP::UserAgent>, in that order.
So:
$fo = open http "http://www.yahoo.com" or die;
would call C<http->open>, consistent with the current Perl
implementation. The only difference would be that C<http> now tries to
call the C<open()> method from C<MyHTTP> and C<LWP::UserAgent>. As such,
the above call would result in the following flow chart:
$fo http->open undef
^ | ^
| | |
| Does MyHTTP::open exist? |
| YES/ \NO |
| / \ |
| Try it Does LWP::UserAgent::open exist? |
| / \ ^ YES/ \NO |
| OK/ \UNDEF / / ----------------
------- ------ Try it |
| / \ |
| OK/ \UNDEF |
------------------------- ---------------------
Some highlights:
1. Each class's open() method is tried in turn.
2. If undef is returned, the next one in sequence
is tried.
3. If 'OK' (simply meaning 1 or some other true
value, like $fo) is returned, that is propagated
out and returned by the top-level handler.
4. All classes are tried until 'OK' is returned
or the last one is reached.
This allows you to easily chain classes and methods together with a
couple key benefits over an inline C<||>:
1. Each handler can partially handle the request,
but still return undef, deferring to the next
one in line.
2. The handlers can be reordered internally at-will
without the main C<open http> code having to be
redone.
3. Different class open() methods can use internal
rules, such as "only open .com URLs", without
you having to put checks for this all over the
place in the top-level program.
Note that C<open()> is the name of the method called on each class
because that is the name of the method called on the C<http> handler.
If:
http->bob(@stuff);
was called, then C<MyHTTP::bob> and C<LWP::UserAgent::bob> would be
attempted, in that order.
=head2 Removing Handlers
In addition to handlers being added, they need to be removed as well.
This is where C<no handler> comes in:
no handler 'http' => 'MyHTTP'; # remove MyHTTP from list
no handler 'http'; # remove http handler
The first example removes C<MyHTTP> from the list of classes used by the
C<http> handler. The second syntax removes the C<http> handler entirely,
meaning that this call:
$fo = open http "http://www.yahoo.com";
will result in the familiar error:
Can't locate object method "open" via package "http"
This should obey blocks as well (like C<strict>), allowing you to say:
{
# force LWP::UserAgent to be used
no handler 'http' => 'MyHTTP';
$fo = open http "http://www.yahoo.com";
}
$fo2 = open http "https://www.etrade.com";
=head2 Automatic Handler Registration and Deregistration
When a class is imported, it should be able to automatically register as
a member of a certain C<handler>. For example, the above code would be
better written as:
use MyHTTP; # these register as 'http'
use LWP::UserAgent; # handlers automatically
$fo = open http "http://www.yahoo.com";
This means that there needs to be some mechanism for a module to execute
the equivalent of a 'use handler' statement, but have it take affect in
the package C<main>. The easiest way it seems is to simply qualify the
full package name you want to affect:
package MyHTTP;
use handler 'main::http' => 'MyHTTP';
This borders on scary action-at-a-distance, though, and should be used
with care.
=head1 IMPLEMENTATION
A complete Perl 5 implementation of this can be found as Class::Handler
http://www.perl.com/CPAN/authors/id/N/NW/NWIGER/Class-Handler-1.03.tar.gz
The Perl 5 implementation uses two functions, C<handler> and
<nohandler>, instead of the pragmatic style proposed in the RFC. This
style may be more appropriate, depending how these are used. One problem
with pragmas is that they are compile-time-only, meaning that
dynamically changing handler lists is tricky to say the least.
A module may remain the best implementation for this, the only problems
are with speed (since the Perl 5 version requires AUTOLOAD) and also
using this mechanism for core methods (like the new C<open> from RFC
14).
=head1 REFERENCES
RFC 14: Modify open() to support FileObjects and Extensibility
RFC 8: The AUTOLOAD subroutine should be able to decline a request
http://www.mail-archive.com/perl6-language-io@perl.org/msg00086.html
