[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> Ann Sanfedele wrote:
> >Three people I care about have serious weight problems, it's killing them,
> none of them are comfortable with having their picture taken. The all hate it.
> So I may have an extra reason for being disturbed by the picture.
>
> I have felt much better once I knew Shel did not really hide the camera.
>
> Your issues with fat are your issues with fat. They are not mine. I am with
> Graywolf here, some people are jumping to the conclusion this woman is pathetic
> simply by her existence (of being fat), and therefore one shouldn't take her
> picture.

Acutally, Shel felt uncomforatble with it.  I would, too, and I'm not saying that my
vision is
any one elses.  I also wrote you and Graywolf privately about further reasons I 
pounced on

Shell for showing it to us - that I wish not to be made public.

I would never take pictures of someone who was injured, for instance, myself.  There is
no judgement on my part about them, but I can't look at them.  I of course am reminded
of my neice when  look at this woman, and what I see is death looming.  Of course it is
my problem.  If this woman didnt care, fine - but she was not given the opportunity.

I think taking pictures of strangers at this close range whether they are beautiful or
homely is intrusive and should never be shown   Unless the person in question has
been consulted first.

I'll confess I find it difficult to look at her,  I  should be lying if I did not.  I
don't like
looking at pictures of me either, Marnie.

annsan

Reply via email to