>> The 1.4 performs way better at f/1.4 than the f/1.7 does. :-) :-)
>> :-)

> Not the 2 A50/1.4 that I had. The A50/1.7 was noticably sharper at
> wide open. The 50/1.4 wasn't sharp until f4, similar to the
> FA*84/1.4.

My experience with some A 50/1.4's and A 50/1.7's differs.  I found
the A 50/1.4's to be slightly sharper at f/1.4 than the A 50/1.7's
at f/1.7, and the advantage would continue at f/2, f/2.8, etc.,
until at about f/8 they would essentially be the same.

Yes, I do know that resolution is not everything, but -
http://www.cetussoft.com/pentax/resolutn.htm

By the way, I also found that the A 50/2 seemed to be as sharp as
the A 50/1.7 aperture-for-aperture (except at f/1.7, of course -
<g>).

About the only advantage I have ever seen for the 50/1.7 over the
50/1.4 was in field flatness (which seemed significant for macro
shooting with the Vivitar 2X macro-focusing TC).

I no longer have any 50/1.7's.  When I want a 50, it's usually an A
50/1.4 that gets pressed into service.  I can use the A 50/1.2 when
I know (or suspect) I'll be facing really low-light conditions, and
I also still have a couple of A 50/2's - they're not really worth
trying to sell, and the ~A~ 50/2 is a surprisingly good lens, and it
is useful to leave "kicking around" in the "workhorse lens kit bag"
(it's sort of my "purgatory" for lenses - <g>) in the trunk of the
car...

Fred

Reply via email to