> - he chooses not the finest grained film but complains about grain Yes and no. He starts out by saying that he's comparing the film he actually uses. For instance, he may need the speed or the color reproduction of the film he choses. From there, it's reasonable to talk about the grain.
If he were starting out specifically stating that he were comparing the most grainless film to digital, it would be another story. But he isn't, and so he doesn't. This does not seem inconsistent or flawed to me. --Mike
