Hi Dhruv, Thanks for your review and suggestions! That really helps to progress the this work. Please see in-line with Quan.
[Pce] draft-xiong-pce-detnet-bounded-latency-00 Dhruv Dhody <dhruv.i...@gmail.com> Fri, 22 July 2022 18:28 UTCShow header Hi, I am not able to understand how you would be adding the Queuing Information Structure in ERO (it has not space)? While it is possible to add Queue Information Structure to SR-ERO/SRv6-ERO sub-object (similar to the SRv6 SID structure), we need to staop and think if it is the correct approach? To me defining them as new sub-objects makes more sense, similar to Label or Hop Attributes! And think what would be the best way to signal them in RSVP-TE in parallel. Quan>Thanks for your suggestion. Adding Queue Information Structure to the existing ERO/SR-ERO/SRv6-ERO sub-objects or proposing new Queuing sub-objects both make sense for us. Maybe we could consider the new sub-objects in next version. We are open to the PCEP extensions and we will consider the feasibility and the RSVP-TE signaling in next version. *Common comments to both DetNet drafts -- Perhaps it would be a good idea to first list out all the requirements for PCEP. We could then get a confirmation of those requirements from DetNet. I also note that both drafts have different terminology.- PCE WG can then decide the best strategy to encode this, where reusing the existing objects makes sense and where defining a new one would be a better strategy.- We should take the possible RSVP-TE signaling into consideration Quan>This draft has been proposed in February and presented at 113 DetNet meeting. The DetNet chair suggested me to bring this proposal to PCE WG as well.Maybe we could list the requirement and extensions and then DetNet and PCE could decide that it is important or not and which WG for this work to progress. Welcome people who are interested in PCEP extensions for DetNet to join us. * Hope this helps! Thanks! Dhruv [Pce] draft-xiong-pce-detnet-bounded-latency-00 Dhruv Dhody _______________________________________________ Pce mailing list Pce@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/pce
