> > I don't even see a need for this. The offset should be within one 1/2
> page, of
> > one bank. So offset >= 0 and <= 127. Length is also > 0 and
> > <- 127. And offset+length is <= 127.
> 
> I like the clean approach, but...   How do you request low memory?

Duh!

I got my conditions wrong. Too focused on 1/2 pages to think that two
of them makes one page!

Lets try again:

offset < 256
0 < len < 128

if (offset < 128)
   offset + len < 128
else
   offset + len < 256

Does that look better?

Reading bytes from the lower 1/2 of page 0 should give the same data
as reading data from the lower 1/2 of page 42. So we can allow that,
but don't be too surprised when an SFP gets it wrong and gives you
rubbish. I would suggest ethtool(1) never actually does read from the
lower 1/2 of any page other than 0.

And i agree about documentation. I would suggest a comment in
ethtool_netlink.h, and the RST documentation.

                   Andrew

Reply via email to