#2951: mutt-1.5.16: smtp error 550 causes blocking
---------------------------------------+------------------------------------
Reporter: errordevelo...@gmail.com | Owner: brendan
Type: defect | Status: assigned
Priority: major | Milestone: 1.6
Component: SMTP | Version:
Resolution: | Keywords:
---------------------------------------+------------------------------------
Changes (by morty):
* status: infoneeded => assigned
Comment:
{{{
I have a similar problem with mutt talking SMTP to an Exchange server.
mutt 1.5.18. Mine
involves SMTP auth+TLS. Error 454 happens late in the email. If I send
email normally, with
the "From" address set the way the Exchange server likes, all is well.
But when I "bounce"
messages, the envelope "mail from" (which has my Exchange mail address)
doesn't match the header
From: (which has the address of the person whose mail I seek to bounce.)
*After* the data
section and the ".", the exchange server sends an error 454. At this
point, mutt reports the
error and hangs.
Here is the end section of -d2 debug output, highly-sanitized:
Connected to smtp02.SOMEDOMAIN:25 on fd=5
5< 220 smtp02.SOMEDOMAIN Microsoft ESMTP MAIL Service, Version:
6.0.3790.3959 ready at Tue, 3 Mar 2009 20:11:07 -0600
5> EHLO HOSTNAME.SOMEDOMAIN
5< 250-smtp02.SOMEDOMAIN
5< 250-TURN
5< 250-SIZE 20480000
5< 250-ETRN
5< 250-PIPELINING
5< 250-DSN
5< 250-ENHANCEDSTATUSCODES
5< 250-8bitmime
5< 250-BINARYMIME
5< 250-CHUNKING
5< 250-VRFY
5< 250-TLS
5< 250-STARTTLS
5< 250-X-LINK2STATE
5< 250-XEXCH50
5< 250 OK
5> STARTTLS
5< 220 2.0.0 SMTP server ready
5> EHLO HOSTNAME.SOMEDOMAIN
5< 250-smtp02.SOMEDOMAIN Hello [SOMEIP0]
5< 250-TURN
5< 250-SIZE 20480000
5< 250-ETRN
5< 250-PIPELINING
5< 250-DSN
5< 250-ENHANCEDSTATUSCODES
5< 250-8bitmime
5< 250-BINARYMIME
5< 250-CHUNKING
5< 250-VRFY
5< 250-X-EXPS LOGIN
5< 250-X-EXPS=LOGIN
5< 250-AUTH LOGIN
5< 250-AUTH=LOGIN
5< 250-X-LINK2STATE
5< 250-XEXCH50
5< 250 OK
SASL local ip: SOMEIP1;57516, remote ip:SOMEIP2;25
External SSF: 128
External authentication name: NTDOMAIN\USER
5> AUTH LOGIN
5< 334 SOMEHASH0
mutt_sasl_cb_authname: getting authname for smtp02.SOMEDOMAIN:25
mutt_sasl_cb_pass: getting password for ntdomain\u...@smtp02.somedomain:25
5> SOMEHASH1
5< 334 SOMEHASH2
5> SOMEHASH3
5< 235 2.7.0 Authentication successful.
5> MAIL FROM:<mailusern...@somedomain>
5< 250 2.1.0 mailusern...@somedomain....sender OK
5> RCPT TO:<mailusern...@somedomain>
5< 250 2.1.5 mailusern...@somedomain
Updating progress: 0
5> DATA
5< 354 Start mail input; end with <CRLF>.<CRLF>
Updating progress: 54
Updating progress: 98
Updating progress: 163
Updating progress: 215
Updating progress: 263
Updating progress: 334
Updating progress: 414
Updating progress: 447
Updating progress: 484
Updating progress: 542
Updating progress: 581
Updating progress: 625
Updating progress: 690
Updating progress: 751
Updating progress: 785
Updating progress: 803
Updating progress: 864
Updating progress: 921
Updating progress: 976
Updating progress: 1033
Updating progress: 1034
Updating progress: 1070
Updating progress: 1071
Updating progress: 1118
Updating progress: 1119
Updating progress: 1194
Updating progress: 1242
Updating progress: 1265
Updating progress: 1266
Updating progress: 1332
Updating progress: 1358
Updating progress: 1392
Updating progress: 1393
Updating progress: 1438
Updating progress: 1497
Updating progress: 1498
Updating progress: 1545
Updating progress: 1583
Updating progress: 1584
Updating progress: 1623
Updating progress: 1675
Updating progress: 1676
Updating progress: 1725
Updating progress: 1740
Updating progress: 1754
Updating progress: 1782
Updating progress: 1839
Updating progress: 1840
Updating progress: 1887
Updating progress: 1916
Updating progress: 1917
Updating progress: 1933
Updating progress: 2018
Updating progress: 2086
Updating progress: 2156
Updating progress: 2220
Updating progress: 2304
Updating progress: 2368
Updating progress: 2400
Updating progress: 2490
Updating progress: 2552
Updating progress: 2633
Updating progress: 2717
Updating progress: 2788
Updating progress: 2865
Updating progress: 2913
Updating progress: 3072
Updating progress: 3118
Updating progress: 3146
Updating progress: 3185
Updating progress: 3245
Updating progress: 3284
Updating progress: 3304
Updating progress: 3342
Updating progress: 3406
Updating progress: 3424
Updating progress: 3449
Updating progress: 3481
Updating progress: 3557
Updating progress: 3566
Updating progress: 3588
Updating progress: 3589
Updating progress: 3691
Updating progress: 3692
Updating progress: 3741
5> .
5< 454 5.7.3 Client does not have permission to Send As this sender.
SMTP session failed: 454 5.7.3 Client does not have permission to Send As
this sender.
At this point, mutt hangs.
I think this should be enough to demo the problem. If you need more,
please let me know.
}}}
--
Ticket URL: <http://dev.mutt.org/trac/ticket/2951#comment:3>
Mutt <http://www.mutt.org/>
The Mutt mail user agent
