Cristov Russell wrote: >>>>Jan van Thiel wrote: >> >>>>> > Another question is: what DVDs do we allow to be added? >> >>>>Audio DVD for >>>> >> >>>>>>certain, but what about video DVD rips and the like? >>>>>> >>>>>>-- >>>>>>Jan van Thiel >>>>>> >> >>>> >>>>live DVD rips (IMO) should be added as live/bootleg and >>>>follow the live/bootleg naming scheme. >>>> >>>>-b. >>>> > >> >> >> The source of the audio is still official so it should not be bootleg.
ripping audio from a live concert DVD is not an official audio release! ripping the audio off of a live concert DVD is An unofficial/underground release that was not sanctioned by the artist and/or the record company. if it were a release officially sanctioned by the artist and/or their record company, than it would be an album from a CD and not ripped audio from a live concert DVD. There is nothing official about it. >> If we >> follow that argument the entire database should be bootlegged. no, it would not leave the entire database as bootleg. it would make the live concert DVD rips bootlegs where the source is the DVD (aka DSBD as far as live recording sources are labled outside of MB). Please expand on this, because it makes no sense to me how ripping out audio of a concert DVD is anything but a bootleg. _______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list Musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
