Greg Oster wrote:

I worry more about a hardware RAID card forgetting its configuration after a power outage than I do about parity checking in the background :) ("What do you mean these 14 disks in this 2TB hardware RAID array are now all 'unassigned'!?!?!?!". That wasn't a fun day.)


Really? We've had something similar happening to us a while ago. The system was running on a 3 disk RAID 5 array. A supermicro backplane went up in flames[1] and the server was shut down. An engineer booted the server without the backplane, but with one disk missing from the RAID 5 array, so upon next boot the missing disk was connected and a rebuild was ordered.

However, the rebuild was taking too long and the server was rebooted to do the rebuild in the background. The server came up fine and we were searching for the necessary tools to start the background rebuild. We thought we were in the clear when suddenly windows started acting all weird, eventually crashed (I didn't see if it was a bluescreen, we were working via terminal server at that time), and the server was rebooted again. After this incident, the controller configuration was gone and all three disks appeared as "Ready". Gone was the RAID.

We eventually were able to recover some data by re-creating the array (luckily someone knew the blocksize originally used) and not initializing when reconstructing the RAID. The operating system was foobar though and couldn't be booted anymore.

This was with an intel-rebranded LSI card with an intel BIOS.

Anyone got any similar experiences with hardware RAID cards? Hardware RAID has always been misery for me.


[1] http://users.opengate.be/~glenn/album/index.php?folder=/Misc/Burnt%20Supermicro%20Backplane/

Reply via email to