Hello, > Is some...@mydomain.tld a valid user as far as OpenSMTPd is concerned? > That is, if you send a message directly to that address, does it get > delivered? Yes. I have Thunderbird with all these test accounts set up. I doublechecked the second address, it is OK and when I write to this email directly it arrives to the right inbox.
If I connect with "telnet localhost 25" sitting in the mail server console and write during the session: "rcpt to:<some...@mydomain.tld" it says: "250 2.1.5 Destination address valid: Recipient ok" I get the same result if I use an external address instead of some...@mydomain.tld in a sieve rule. I can email to any external address directly but redirecting via sieve to that same address fails with the same error in the log. Btw, I already set up redirection by means of OpenSMTPD with SRS and it works. But now I would like to have the similar functionality available to a mail user as a user. On Thu Feb 20 09:30:19 2025, Zé Loff wrote: > On Thu, Feb 20, 2025 at 10:11:03AM +0300, Maksim Rodin wrote: > > Hello, > > I am trying to use sieve to forward or redirect messages > > after they reach the dovecot service on my mail server. > > My sieve rule for the mail user "some...@mydomain.tld" > > contains a single line: > > > > """ > > redirect "some...@mydomain.tld"; > > """ > > > > After enabling this rule and sending mail to the mailbox > > "some...@mydomain.tld" I see the following it the maillog: > > > > """ > > 1) Feb 20 09:18:21 mail smtpd[6741]: 6979ad3753eb0f9d smtp failed-command > > command="RCPT TO:<some...@mydomain.tld> " > > result="550 Invalid recipient: <some...@mydomain.tld>" > > 2) Feb 20 09:18:21 mail dovecot: lmtp: Error: sendmail: command failed: > > 550 Invalid recipient: <some...@mydomain.tld> > > 3) Feb 20 09:18:21 mail dovecot: lmtp(some...@mydomain.tld)<39847> > > <oA1MJC3JtmenmwAAZU03Dg>: Error: > > sieve: msgid=<7224e316-1b0f-4c00-b5df-4302523d2...@mydomain.tld>: > > redirect action: failed to redirect message to <some...@mydomain.tld>: > > Sendmail program returned error (temporary failure) > > """ > > > > I suppose OpenSMTPD does not like the "RCPT TO:" part of the mail > > transaction. I only noticed that the error in the log shows an additional > > space > > after the address: > > """ > > smtp failed-command command="RCPT TO:<some...@mydomain.tld> " > > """ > > > > but I am not sure if I can do something with this. > > I tried to write the rule like this: > > > > """ > > redirect "<some...@mydomain.tld>"; > > """ > > > > But nothing changed. > > Is this a problem with dovecot or OpenSMTPD? > > > > OpenBSD 6.7 stable > > dovecot 2.3.21.1 (d492236fa0) > > OpenSMTPD 7.6.0 > > > > -- > > Best regards > > Maksim Rodin > > > > FWIW, I have accounts with 'redirect "x...@mydomain.tld";' rules that are > correctly forwarded by OpenSMTPd (7.6-stable, also with Dovecot). > > Is some...@mydomain.tld a valid user as far as OpenSMTPd is concerned? > That is, if you send a message directly to that address, does it get > delivered? > > > -- > -- Best regards Maksim Rodin С уважением, Родин Максим
