On Wed, 3 Feb 2016 23:09:39 +0000 Tarkan Açan <tarkan.a...@sodium.com.tr> wrote:
> hello misc, > > i am using openbsd 5.8 amd64 on my apu 1d4 with success but i have > one big problem. the queue mechanism in pf allows some traffic > shaping but what i really need is to give users their share of the > bandwidth. for this i need some connection based algorithm like sfq > (linux) or cbq (mikrotik - routeros). i have read and searched around > a lot but it seems not possible to do such a thing with pf. is it > possible to arrange this kind of bandwith sharing with a proxy like > relayd? does anybody have suggestions? all feedback is sincerely > appreciated. >From my experience with queueing in 5.8 amd64 on APU, there shouldn't be a problem if you use fixed bandwidth allocation where target bandwidth and max bandwidth are the same, similar to: ---cut-here--- queue dowload on $int_if bandwidth 20M max 20M queue user1 parent download bandwidth 5M max 5M queue user2 parent download bandwidth 5M max 5M queue user3 parent download bandwidth 5M max 5M queue default parent download bandwidth 5M max 5M default match to $user1 set queue user1 match to $user2 set queue user2 match to $user2 set queue user2 ---cut-here--- If you need something more advanced, like granting minimum bandwidth with the ability to borrow from other queues up to maximum bandwidth when other queues are empty, I am afraid you won't be able to do it with current queueing system. However, I'm still hoping one of these days someone will prove me wrong. Regards, -- Before enlightenment - chop wood, draw water. After enlightenment - chop wood, draw water. Marko Cupać https://www.mimar.rs/
