=== "Ben Dibell" <thinkingrod...@gmail.com> wrote:
=== 
===> Hi, I've tried other resources, even reading the
source for init, but I
===> can't seem to locate the magic that
makes /sbin/init the approved init.
===> I'm porting my init
system Epoch to BSD for personal reasons, and I'd
===> like
===> it to work under OpenBSD, which I've been enjoying as of late. I
come
===> from
===> the linux world where init=/bin/sh is
perfectly valid, so some aspects
===> are
===> probably
simpler in Linux. I am hoping there is a concise and clean
===>
explanation as to how to write/port an init system to BSD. Is it signal
===> trickery? A checksum burned into the kernel? I'm lost. I'm given
"init
===> has
===> died, signal 0 exit 0" or
something nearly identical to this. There are
===> no
===>
further useful debug messages and my keyboard becomes unresponsive on
===> the
===> debugging prompt or the kernel locks up or
something, so I can't do more
===> there.
===>
===> Thanks for your time.
===>
===> -Ben
===

=== The kernel doesn't support any command line syntax like that but
I don't
=== know why it wouldn't let you use any static binary. You
should read
=== kernel sources too if you're serious about this.
=== 
=== But I don't see your point. Obviously you can do what
makes you happy on
=== your systems but have you thought about what
OpenBSD init does vs. what
=== your init does? init (among other
things) exists to run getty and start
=== /etc/rc. You mention status
in a further message. You probably want to
=== keep logs and manage
daemon state like the other newfangled init
=== systems. You're going
to have to rewrite both init and the rc system.
=== And you won't get
any support for such a system.
=== 
=== And if you want to
monitor daemons you'll be better off monitoring the
=== service the
daemons are supposed to provide. It doesn't matter if httpd
===
hasn't exited yet if you can't connect to it.
=== 
=== - Martin
Brandenburg
=== 

Well, I'm not asking for anyone to
support me once I get it going. Right now I just want to get stdout/stderr
working and perhaps I can get it running in a crippled but visibly
semi-functional state so I can continue my work porting.

Reply via email to