We're planning on upgrading some mail servers with 3.7, .. but we're having an internal 'debate' over the architecture.

Keeping things simple (sendmail - don't need antoher MTA debate!), the question is three-fold:

1) Vilter/Milter - using sendmail to scan incoming messages in realtime.

Pro: Reject messages before being accepted.
Con: Possibility of locking up sendmail daemon; performance hit for large messages.


2) Mainscanner - passing emails to external programs for scanning virus/spam.

    Pro:        Can be restarted automatically if a scan crashes.
    Con:        Messages are accepted even if invalid.

3) Amavisd - alternative to Mainscanner, same architecture

4) Cyrus - doesn't seem to be a package nor complete port in the tree?

There are a variety of notes available, but not a lot of good information about *why*. Prefer to stay with sendmail as it's in the base install, and we have used SM/MS/ClamAV/SA in the past with some success so there's a little intertia towards that solution.

Any pointers to good resources for details would be greatly appreciated.

        Lee



Reply via email to