On Sun, Jan 11, 2015 at 7:08 PM, Connor Abbott <cwabbo...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Tue, Jan 6, 2015 at 5:21 PM, Jason Ekstrand <ja...@jlekstrand.net> > wrote: > > > > > > On Mon, Jan 5, 2015 at 10:00 PM, Jason Ekstrand <ja...@jlekstrand.net> > > wrote: > >> > >> > >> > >> On Mon, Jan 5, 2015 at 9:12 PM, Connor Abbott <cwabbo...@gmail.com> > wrote: > >>> > >>> Hi, > >>> > >>> Was it your intention to not support non-per-component things like dot > >>> product at all? I've made a few inline comments about how to do it, > >>> and it doesn't seem like it's that hard. > >> > >> > >> No, It was just never tested on them. All your comments seem valid > >> enough. I'll try and incorperate them. > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> On Tue, Dec 16, 2014 at 1:12 AM, Jason Ekstrand <ja...@jlekstrand.net> > >>> wrote: > >>> > > >>> > This framework provides a simple way to do simple search-and-replace > >>> > operations on NIR code. The nir_search.h header provides four simple > >>> > data > >>> > structures for representing expressions: nir_value and four > subtypes: > >>> > nir_variable, nir_constant, and nir_expression. An expression tree > can > >>> > >>> Make these be the actual names (nir_search_value, nir_search_variable, > >>> etc.) > >> > >> > >> Yeah, no problem. > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> > then be represented by nesting these data structures as needed. The > >>> > nir_replace_instr function takes an instruction, an expression, and a > >>> > value; if the instruction matches the expression, it is replaced > with a > >>> > new > >>> > chain of instructions to generate the given replacement value. The > >>> > framework keeps track of swizzles on sources and automatically > >>> > generates > >>> > the currect swizzles for the replacement value. > >>> > --- > >>> > src/glsl/Makefile.sources | 2 + > >>> > src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c | 337 > >>> > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ > >>> > src/glsl/nir/nir_search.h | 80 +++++++++++ > >>> > 3 files changed, 419 insertions(+) > >>> > create mode 100644 src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c > >>> > create mode 100644 src/glsl/nir/nir_search.h > >>> > > >>> > diff --git a/src/glsl/Makefile.sources b/src/glsl/Makefile.sources > >>> > index 12c1d83..201330d 100644 > >>> > --- a/src/glsl/Makefile.sources > >>> > +++ b/src/glsl/Makefile.sources > >>> > @@ -41,6 +41,8 @@ NIR_FILES = \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_opt_peephole_select.c \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_print.c \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_remove_dead_variables.c \ > >>> > + $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_search.c \ > >>> > + $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_search.h \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_split_var_copies.c \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_to_ssa.c \ > >>> > $(GLSL_SRCDIR)/nir/nir_validate.c \ > >>> > diff --git a/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c b/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c > >>> > new file mode 100644 > >>> > index 0000000..257a53b > >>> > --- /dev/null > >>> > +++ b/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c > >>> > @@ -0,0 +1,337 @@ > >>> > +/* > >>> > + * Copyright © 2014 Intel Corporation > >>> > + * > >>> > + * Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person > >>> > obtaining a > >>> > + * copy of this software and associated documentation files (the > >>> > "Software"), > >>> > + * to deal in the Software without restriction, including without > >>> > limitation > >>> > + * the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, > >>> > sublicense, > >>> > + * and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom > >>> > the > >>> > + * Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following > >>> > conditions: > >>> > + * > >>> > + * The above copyright notice and this permission notice (including > >>> > the next > >>> > + * paragraph) shall be included in all copies or substantial > portions > >>> > of the > >>> > + * Software. > >>> > + * > >>> > + * THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, > >>> > EXPRESS OR > >>> > + * IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF > >>> > MERCHANTABILITY, > >>> > + * FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO > EVENT > >>> > SHALL > >>> > + * THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES > >>> > OR OTHER > >>> > + * LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, > >>> > ARISING > >>> > + * FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR > OTHER > >>> > DEALINGS > >>> > + * IN THE SOFTWARE. > >>> > + * > >>> > + * Authors: > >>> > + * Jason Ekstrand (ja...@jlekstrand.net) > >>> > + * > >>> > + */ > >>> > + > >>> > +#include "nir_search.h" > >>> > + > >>> > +struct match_state { > >>> > + unsigned variables_seen; > >>> > + nir_alu_src variables[NIR_SEARCH_MAX_VARIABLES]; > >>> > +}; > >>> > + > >>> > +static bool > >>> > +is_commutative_binop(nir_op op) > >>> > +{ > >>> > + switch (op) { > >>> > + case nir_op_fadd: > >>> > + case nir_op_iadd: > >>> > + case nir_op_fmul: > >>> > + case nir_op_imul: > >>> > + case nir_op_imul_high: > >>> > + case nir_op_umul_high: > >>> > + case nir_op_feq: > >>> > + case nir_op_fne: > >>> > + case nir_op_ieq: > >>> > + case nir_op_ine: > >>> > + case nir_op_fand: > >>> > + case nir_op_for: > >>> > + case nir_op_fxor: > >>> > + case nir_op_iand: > >>> > + case nir_op_ior: > >>> > + case nir_op_ixor: > >>> > + case nir_op_fmin: > >>> > + case nir_op_fmax: > >>> > + case nir_op_imin: > >>> > + case nir_op_imax: > >>> > + case nir_op_umin: > >>> > + case nir_op_umax: > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + default: > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + } > >>> > +} > >>> > + > >>> > +static bool > >>> > +match_expression(const nir_search_expression *expr, nir_alu_instr > >>> > *instr, > >>> > + unsigned num_components, const uint8_t *swizzle, > >>> > + struct match_state *state); > >>> > + > >>> > +static bool > >>> > +match_value(const nir_search_value *value, nir_alu_instr *instr, > >>> > unsigned src, > >>> > + unsigned num_components, const uint8_t *swizzle, > >>> > + struct match_state *state) > >>> > +{ > >>> > + uint8_t new_swizzle[4]; > >>> > + > >>> > + for (int i = 0; i < num_components; ++i) > >>> > + new_swizzle[i] = instr->src[src].swizzle[swizzle[i]]; > >>> > + > >>> > + switch (value->type) { > >>> > + case nir_search_value_expression: > >>> > + if (!instr->src[src].src.is_ssa) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + if (instr->src[src].src.ssa->parent_instr->type != > >>> > nir_instr_type_alu) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + return match_expression(nir_search_value_as_expression(value), > >>> > + > >>> > nir_instr_as_alu(instr->src[src].src.ssa->parent_instr), > >>> > + num_components, new_swizzle, state); > >>> > + > >>> > + case nir_search_value_variable: { > >>> > + nir_search_variable *var = > nir_search_value_as_variable(value); > >>> > + > >>> > + if (state->variables_seen & (1 << var->variable)) { > >>> > + if (!nir_srcs_equal(state->variables[0].src, > >>> > instr->src[src].src)) > >>> > >>> I think you meant state->variables[var->variable].src here. > >> > >> > >> Yes, I think you're right. Kind of curious that this worked... > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> > > >>> > + return false; > >>> > > >>> > + > >>> > + assert(!instr->src[src].abs && !instr->src[src].negate); > >>> > + > >>> > + for (int i = 0; i < num_components; ++i) { > >>> > + if (state->variables[var->variable].swizzle[i] != > >>> > new_swizzle[i]) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + } else { > >>> > + state->variables_seen |= (1 << var->variable); > >>> > + state->variables[var->variable].src = instr->src[src].src; > >>> > + state->variables[var->variable].abs = false; > >>> > + state->variables[var->variable].negate = false; > >>> > + > >>> > + for (int i = 0; i < 4; ++i) { > >>> > + if (i < num_components) > >>> > + state->variables[var->variable].swizzle[i] = > >>> > new_swizzle[i]; > >>> > + else > >>> > + state->variables[var->variable].swizzle[i] = 0; > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + } > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + case nir_search_value_constant: { > >>> > + nir_search_constant *const_val = > >>> > nir_search_value_as_constant(value); > >>> > + > >>> > + if (!instr->src[src].src.is_ssa) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + if (instr->src[src].src.ssa->parent_instr->type != > >>> > nir_instr_type_load_const) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_load_const_instr *load = > >>> > + > >>> > nir_instr_as_load_const(instr->src[src].src.ssa->parent_instr); > >>> > + > >>> > + switch (nir_op_infos[instr->op].input_types[src]) { > >>> > + case nir_type_float: > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < num_components; ++i) { > >>> > + if (load->value.f[new_swizzle[i]] != const_val->data.f) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + } > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + case nir_type_int: > >>> > + case nir_type_unsigned: > >>> > + case nir_type_bool: > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < num_components; ++i) { > >>> > + if (load->value.i[new_swizzle[i]] != const_val->data.i) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + } > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + default: > >>> > + unreachable("Invalid alu source type"); > >>> > + } > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + default: > >>> > + unreachable("Invalid search value type"); > >>> > + } > >>> > +} > >>> > + > >>> > +static bool > >>> > +match_expression(const nir_search_expression *expr, nir_alu_instr > >>> > *instr, > >>> > + unsigned num_components, const uint8_t *swizzle, > >>> > + struct match_state *state) > >>> > +{ > >>> > + if (instr->op != expr->opcode) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + assert(!instr->dest.saturate); > >>> > + assert(nir_op_infos[instr->op].num_inputs > 0); > >>> > >>> > >>> If the instruction has a sized destination, we ought to bail out if > >>> the swizzle isn't the identity or num_components isn't equal to the > >>> identity for those components. Alternately, we could assert that the > >>> only instructions with non-per-component destinations are at the root, > >>> since it doesn't seem like there are that many optimizations with a > >>> non-per-component instruction like "dot" or "any" that's not at the > >>> root of the tree. > >> > >> > >> Good point. > > > > > > Yes, we do need to bail on a non-trivial swizzle. However, I think not > > using all the components is probably fine. The validator will ensure > that > > it doesn't use more components and not using all of them shouldn't be a > > problem. > > On second thought, I think you're right. We only need to bail on a > non-trivial swizzle. > FYI: I did make all those changes. They're sigging in my repo: http://cgit.freedesktop.org/~jekstrand/mesa/tree/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.c?h=review/nir-v1 If you want me to resend, I can. Or you can review it there --Jason > > > > >> > >> > >>> > >>> > + > >>> > + bool matched = true; > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < nir_op_infos[instr->op].num_inputs; > i++) { > >>> > + if (!match_value(expr->srcs[i], instr, i, num_components, > >>> > + swizzle, state)) { > >>> > >>> > >>> I think we need to pass in the correct number of components if the > >>> source isn't per-component, since if we don't any optimizations > >>> involving dot products will be totally broken. Similarly, I think we > >>> need to reset the swizzle to the identity here for non-per-component > >>> inputs. > >> > >> > >> Right > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> > > >>> > + matched = false; > >>> > + break; > >>> > + } > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + if (matched) > >>> > + return true; > >>> > + > >>> > + if (is_commutative_binop(instr->op)) { > >>> > + if (!match_value(expr->srcs[0], instr, 1, num_components, > >>> > + swizzle, state)) > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + > >>> > + return match_value(expr->srcs[1], instr, 0, num_components, > >>> > + swizzle, state); > >>> > + } else { > >>> > + return false; > >>> > + } > >>> > +} > >>> > + > >>> > +static nir_alu_src > >>> > +construct_value(const nir_search_value *value, nir_alu_type type, > >>> > + unsigned num_components, struct match_state *state, > >>> > + nir_instr *instr, void *mem_ctx) > >>> > +{ > >>> > + switch (value->type) { > >>> > + case nir_search_value_expression: { > >>> > + const nir_search_expression *expr = > >>> > nir_search_value_as_expression(value); > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_alu_instr *alu = nir_alu_instr_create(mem_ctx, > >>> > expr->opcode); > >>> > + alu->dest.dest.is_ssa = true; > >>> > + nir_ssa_def_init(&alu->instr, &alu->dest.dest.ssa, > >>> > num_components, NULL); > >>> > + alu->dest.write_mask = (1 << num_components) - 1; > >>> > + alu->dest.saturate = false; > >>> > + > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < > nir_op_infos[expr->opcode].num_inputs; > >>> > i++) { > >>> > + alu->src[i] = construct_value(expr->srcs[i], > >>> > + > >>> > nir_op_infos[alu->op].input_types[i], > >>> > + num_components, > >>> > + state, instr, mem_ctx); > >>> > >>> Similarly to my earlier comment, we need to set num_components > >>> correctly here if the source is not per-component. > >> > >> > >> Yup > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_instr_insert_before(instr, &alu->instr); > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_alu_src val = { > >>> > + .src.is_ssa = true, > >>> > + .src.ssa = &alu->dest.dest.ssa, > >>> > + .negate = false, > >>> > + .abs = false, > >>> > + .swizzle = { 0, 0, 0, 0 } > >>> > + }; > >>> > + > >>> > + /* No swizzling, but we can't have a swizzle value higher than > >>> > + * num_components or the validator will get cranky. > >>> > + */ > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < num_components; ++i) > >>> > + val.swizzle[i] = i; > >>> > >>> > >>> The validator only checks swizzle values that are actually being used, > >>> so we can just do > >>> > >>> .swizzle = {0, 1, 2, 3} > >>> > >>> here and it should be fine. > >> > >> > >> Yeah, that should be ok. > >> > >>> > >>> > >>> > > >>> > + > >>> > + return val; > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + case nir_search_value_variable: { > >>> > + const nir_search_variable *var = > >>> > nir_search_value_as_variable(value); > >>> > + assert(state->variables_seen & (1 << var->variable)); > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_alu_src val = state->variables[var->variable]; > >>> > + val.src = nir_src_copy(val.src, mem_ctx); > >>> > + > >>> > + return val; > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + case nir_search_value_constant: { > >>> > + const nir_search_constant *c = > >>> > nir_search_value_as_constant(value); > >>> > + nir_load_const_instr *load = > >>> > nir_load_const_instr_create(mem_ctx); > >>> > + load->dest.is_ssa = true; > >>> > + nir_ssa_def_init(&load->instr, &load->dest.ssa, 1, NULL); > >>> > + > >>> > + switch (type) { > >>> > + case nir_type_float: > >>> > + load->dest.ssa.name = ralloc_asprintf(mem_ctx, "%f", > >>> > c->data.f); > >>> > + load->value.f[0] = c->data.f; > >>> > + break; > >>> > + case nir_type_int: > >>> > + load->dest.ssa.name = ralloc_asprintf(mem_ctx, "%d", > >>> > c->data.i); > >>> > + load->value.i[0] = c->data.i; > >>> > + break; > >>> > + case nir_type_unsigned: > >>> > + case nir_type_bool: > >>> > + load->value.u[0] = c->data.u; > >>> > + break; > >>> > + default: > >>> > + unreachable("Invalid alu source type"); > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_instr_insert_before(instr, &load->instr); > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_alu_src val = { > >>> > + .src.is_ssa = true, > >>> > + .src.ssa = &load->dest.ssa, > >>> > + .negate = false, > >>> > + .abs = false, > >>> > + .swizzle = { 0, 0, 0, 0 } /* Splatted scalar */ > >>> > + }; > >>> > + > >>> > + return val; > >>> > + } > >>> > + > >>> > + default: > >>> > + unreachable("Invalid search value type"); > >>> > + } > >>> > +} > >>> > + > >>> > +nir_alu_instr * > >>> > +nir_replace_instr(nir_alu_instr *instr, const nir_search_expression > >>> > *search, > >>> > + const nir_search_value *replace, void *mem_ctx) > >>> > +{ > >>> > + uint8_t swizzle[4] = { 0, 0, 0, 0 }; > >>> > + > >>> > + for (unsigned i = 0; i < instr->dest.dest.ssa.num_components; > ++i) > >>> > + swizzle[i] = i; > >>> > + > >>> > + assert(instr->dest.dest.is_ssa); > >>> > + > >>> > + struct match_state state; > >>> > + state.variables_seen = 0; > >>> > + > >>> > + if (!match_expression(search, instr, > >>> > instr->dest.dest.ssa.num_components, > >>> > + swizzle, &state)) > >>> > + return NULL; > >>> > + > >>> > + /* Inserting a mov may be unnecessary. However, it's much easier > >>> > to > >>> > + * simply let copy propagation clean this up than to try to go > >>> > through > >>> > + * and rewrite swizzles ourselves. > >>> > + */ > >>> > + nir_alu_instr *mov = nir_alu_instr_create(mem_ctx, nir_op_imov); > >>> > + mov->dest.write_mask = instr->dest.write_mask; > >>> > + mov->dest.dest.is_ssa = true; > >>> > + nir_ssa_def_init(&mov->instr, &mov->dest.dest.ssa, > >>> > + instr->dest.dest.ssa.num_components, NULL); > >>> > + > >>> > + mov->src[0] = construct_value(replace, > >>> > nir_op_infos[instr->op].output_type, > >>> > + > instr->dest.dest.ssa.num_components, > >>> > &state, > >>> > + &instr->instr, mem_ctx); > >>> > + nir_instr_insert_before(&instr->instr, &mov->instr); > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_src replace_src = { > >>> > + .is_ssa = true, > >>> > + .ssa = &mov->dest.dest.ssa, > >>> > + }; > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_ssa_def_rewrite_uses(&instr->dest.dest.ssa, replace_src, > >>> > mem_ctx); > >>> > + > >>> > + /* We know this one has no more uses because we just rewrote them > >>> > all, > >>> > + * so we can remove it. The rest of the matched expression, > >>> > however, we > >>> > + * don't know so much about. We'll just let dead code clean them > >>> > up. > >>> > + */ > >>> > + nir_instr_remove(&instr->instr); > >>> > + > >>> > + return mov; > >>> > +} > >>> > diff --git a/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.h b/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.h > >>> > new file mode 100644 > >>> > index 0000000..8ec58b0 > >>> > --- /dev/null > >>> > +++ b/src/glsl/nir/nir_search.h > >>> > @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ > >>> > +/* > >>> > + * Copyright © 2014 Intel Corporation > >>> > + * > >>> > + * Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person > >>> > obtaining a > >>> > + * copy of this software and associated documentation files (the > >>> > "Software"), > >>> > + * to deal in the Software without restriction, including without > >>> > limitation > >>> > + * the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, > >>> > sublicense, > >>> > + * and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom > >>> > the > >>> > + * Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following > >>> > conditions: > >>> > + * > >>> > + * The above copyright notice and this permission notice (including > >>> > the next > >>> > + * paragraph) shall be included in all copies or substantial > portions > >>> > of the > >>> > + * Software. > >>> > + * > >>> > + * THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, > >>> > EXPRESS OR > >>> > + * IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF > >>> > MERCHANTABILITY, > >>> > + * FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO > EVENT > >>> > SHALL > >>> > + * THE AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES > >>> > OR OTHER > >>> > + * LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, > >>> > ARISING > >>> > + * FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR > OTHER > >>> > DEALINGS > >>> > + * IN THE SOFTWARE. > >>> > + * > >>> > + * Authors: > >>> > + * Jason Ekstrand (ja...@jlekstrand.net) > >>> > + * > >>> > + */ > >>> > + > >>> > +#ifndef _NIR_SEARCH_ > >>> > +#define _NIR_SEARCH_ > >>> > + > >>> > +#include "nir.h" > >>> > + > >>> > +#define NIR_SEARCH_MAX_VARIABLES 16 > >>> > + > >>> > +typedef enum { > >>> > + nir_search_value_expression, > >>> > + nir_search_value_variable, > >>> > + nir_search_value_constant, > >>> > +} nir_search_value_type; > >>> > + > >>> > +typedef struct { > >>> > + nir_search_value_type type; > >>> > +} nir_search_value; > >>> > + > >>> > +typedef struct { > >>> > + nir_search_value value; > >>> > + > >>> > + /** The variable index; Must be less than > NIR_SEARCH_MAX_VARIABLES > >>> > */ > >>> > + unsigned variable; > >>> > +} nir_search_variable; > >>> > + > >>> > +typedef struct { > >>> > + nir_search_value value; > >>> > + > >>> > + union { > >>> > + uint32_t u; > >>> > + int32_t i; > >>> > + float f; > >>> > + } data; > >>> > +} nir_search_constant; > >>> > + > >>> > +typedef struct { > >>> > + nir_search_value value; > >>> > + > >>> > + nir_op opcode; > >>> > + const nir_search_value *srcs[4]; > >>> > +} nir_search_expression; > >>> > + > >>> > +NIR_DEFINE_CAST(nir_search_value_as_variable, nir_search_value, > >>> > + nir_search_variable, value) > >>> > +NIR_DEFINE_CAST(nir_search_value_as_constant, nir_search_value, > >>> > + nir_search_constant, value) > >>> > +NIR_DEFINE_CAST(nir_search_value_as_expression, nir_search_value, > >>> > + nir_search_expression, value) > >>> > + > >>> > +nir_alu_instr * > >>> > +nir_replace_instr(nir_alu_instr *instr, const nir_search_expression > >>> > *search, > >>> > + const nir_search_value *replace, void *mem_ctx); > >>> > + > >>> > +#endif /* _NIR_SEARCH_ */ > >>> > -- > >>> > 2.2.0 > >>> > > >>> > _______________________________________________ > >>> > mesa-dev mailing list > >>> > mesa-dev@lists.freedesktop.org > >>> > http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/mesa-dev > >> > >> > > >
_______________________________________________ mesa-dev mailing list mesa-dev@lists.freedesktop.org http://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/mesa-dev