On 12/03/2018 06:50 PM, Jordan Justen wrote: > Lots of discussion here. :) I hoped to just dip our toes into the > merge request stream, but the consensus is clearly against my idea. Oh > well. :) > > Here's what I gathered from the discussion: > > == Keep email, allow duplicate MR, my idea == > > I don't think anyone else was in favor of this. Several were against > it. > > == NACK merge requests altogether == > > I did not see this, so that seems promising for merge requests. :) I > guess no one strongly disagrees with trying merge requests. > > == Allow submitter (or driver) to choose to email or MR, but not both == > > Several seemed to argue that this could be a good next step. But, in > all those cases, I think they wanted to use merge requests going > forward. > > It was mentioned that vc4 has moved to github in order to allow github > pull requests to be used. > > == Require all email list, or all merge requests == > > A few argued in favor of this, and seemed to feel pretty strongly > about it. In both cases I believe they wanted to more to merge > requests. :) > > == Next step? == > > So, what do you all think is the best next step after the discussion? > > We could take the smaller step to allow the submitter, or project to > decide which they prefer. It would allow those who prefer email to > continue with email, while trying out gitlab merge requests. But, it > could mean that devs need to check both gitlab and email. > > Or, we could just try to make the jump to MR only. Maybe if I write > that patch someone will finally stand up to try to NACK moving away > from email. :) > > Or, are we a little too early for this discussion, and we should just > drop it for now? > > My opinion would be to try to move a bit slower and allow the > submitter/project to choose for a trial period. (Dylan and Daniel seem > to think this could be really frustrating for devs though.) But, if > everyone seems to think it's reasonable to try to jump straight to > using merge requests exclusively, I can type that version up...
FWIW, I'd prefer the trial period where both methods are available. -Brian _______________________________________________ mesa-dev mailing list mesa-dev@lists.freedesktop.org https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/mesa-dev
