* Al Iverson via mailop:

> My answer to the question of why: To make it slightly harder for bad
> guys to pick up and DKIM replay older messages.

The problem I see with trusting the x-tag is that one cannot be sure if
the functionality is implemented, or if the tag is "honored" by third
parties. What is both reliable and controlled by any sending party are
their own DNS RRs. Delete the records for outdated DKIM selectors, and
(barring caching errors) signatures can no longer be validated once the
RR TTL has expired.

How useful that is in the real world is debatable, but rolling DKIM keys
automatically on a weekly basis, for example, requires nothing but a bit
of creative scripting.

-Ralph
_______________________________________________
mailop mailing list
mailop@mailop.org
https://list.mailop.org/listinfo/mailop

Reply via email to