On 2022-01-21 05:21 EST, Ryan Schmidt wrote:
As was already mentioned, the /opt/local/bin/perl symlink is controlled by the perl5 port, so install it with whatever variant you wish.
I had to glance back and forth a couple times there. I… guess you're also "Kastus Shchuka"? :^>
Yes, that was exactly the syntax I didn't remember and couldn't recall enough of to locate in the man page. Thank you!
Unlike most of the other ports like python, php, ruby, and others where you have a choice of version, the perl ports do not use the select mechanism. Modifying them to use the select mechanism (and more specifically modifying every port that currently depends on port:perl5 or path:bin/perl:perl5 to use a specific version of perl) would be a large undertaking, and I'm not sure the benefit would outweigh the drawbacks and the effort involved. https://trac.macports.org/ticket/29763
Oh, for sure!I'm… also not sure it's even actually a good idea, since, in my experience, Perl is much more flexible about newer versions of `perl` functioning with "out-dated" versions of libraries *and* vice versa than, say, PHP is. (I think maybe Python plays better with date-of-release mismatches?)
Ahem: Perl is more flexible, so having more than one version (including whatever Apple deigns to stomp all over `/usr/bin/perl` with in any given release) around only *really* matters in corner cases, even if you take the (questionable: I've made this choice under NetBSD and concluded it was probably a mistake) decision to tell all installed versions about the others' LIBPATHs (while having each version's CPAN module control only its own).
By "flexible", I mean it'll *try*, and well-designed modules will keep traversing the library path till they find a version that'll work for them, but that takes some gymnastics few modules implement in the real world.
But also that trac ticket's been around for 11 years, and has a lot of interest, including recently, and I'm currently unemployed. So… hm.
I only skimmed the ticket just now (and will read it in more detail, because I'm interested), but do you know of prior embarkations down this road?
It is, demonstrably (the responses to that ticket), a UI/UX wart.(Feel free to reply to this one privately, or to move the discussion over to macports-dev, if you think either's more appropriate.)
-- Gabriel Rosenkoetter (he/him) g...@eclipsed.net
OpenPGP_signature
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
