On May 1, 2013, at 8:28 PM, Scott Kostyshak wrote:

> On Wed, May 1, 2013 at 10:59 PM, Jerry <lancebo...@qwest.net> wrote:
> 
>> A while back I spent a lot of time evaluating the various  ways to convert 
>> LyX to .odt or .docx and found that none of them work well.
> 
> You seemed more impressed a few months ago :)
> "Mostly successful experiment: LyX -> LaTeX -> Word using pandoc"
> http://comments.gmane.org/gmane.editors.lyx.general/76375
> 
> But I imagine that sometimes "mostly" successful is still a failure if
> a few key features are missing.
> 
> Note that Pandoc support in LyX seems like it's just waiting for
> someone to make a patch:
> http://www.lyx.org/trac/ticket/6042

Good catch, Scott. But with a little more investigation later, my perception of 
this route went down substantially. I commented in a thread, "Re: Word won't 
open simplest LyXHTML file," which mysteriously does not appear in the archive 
at the above site. So here is partial replay from 2013-01-22:

"LyX -> LaTeX (plain) -> docx using pandoc:

Word (Mac 2011) complains "This file is corrupt and cannot be opened." It then 
offers to repair the file. Results are: inline equation translated and editable 
but with two minor errors (it did not recognize lim as a function and set it in 
italics)--this shows that equation translation _can_ work; standalone equation 
not translated, TeX code is displayed between two $ signs, and equation number 
is lost; image caption is lost, but the spurious word "image" is displayed 
nearby; labels (section, equation) are set as ordinary text within their 
respective domains; cross-references are displayed as ordinary text but with 
nonexistent links; comments are displayed as normal text but in a separate 
paragraph, thus splitting the paragraph in which it is contained into two 
paragraphs; and indexed terms are lost.


LyX -> LaTeX (plain) -> odt using pandoc:
Opened with LibreOffice. The file is reported as corrupt and the program offers 
to repair it. Results--similar to above for Word except: inline equation is 
very poorly typeset and is not editable using the built-in equation editor; 
instead of the picture that was supposed to be a figure, a box is displayed 
which reads "Read error"; the word "image" is not displayed; clicking on the 
footnote cross reference moves the cursor to the crossreference;"

Jerry
> 
> Scott

Reply via email to