>>>>> "Abdelrazak" == Abdelrazak Younes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes:

>>  Wait a minute. I do not think we want to add all these things to
>> our source tree! Please don't do that.

Abdelrazak> Is it a disk space problem or a religious issue?

We try to avoid hosting code that is not ours because

- it indeed takes up disk space

- then we are responsible for maintaining it

- this is even more important when the code is only used on one
  platform. Linux and OSX can use the system aspell.

There are currently two exceptions that I know of

- boost, because it used to be a moving target and we can never be
  sure that our code will work with system boost. If the situation is
  better now, we should probably reconsider

- gettext, because this is what the GNU standards told us to do. I
  read somewhere that this stance has changed and that several GNU
  tools suites stopped doing that. If it is true, we should also
  reconsider.

Concerning the aspell problem, it would be maybe better (for 1.5) to
change our code to use Enchant or something like that which is able to
use system dictionaries.

Instead of distributing modified sources, we can have a patch in our
source tree, and provide binaries in ftp.lyx.org/pub/lyx/contrib.

So, I do not know how religious the arguments turns out to be, but as
far as I am concerned, it boils down to "avoid trouble" and "let
others handle their stuff".

JMarc 

Reply via email to