< sorry for the PM to Leeming. >

> Loading an existing document containing such an inset results in no 
> previews being generated at all, as now.

Locating a wrong formula among others is extremely difficult (may have 
to compile all formulas one by one.) so there is no good solution yet.

> In conclusion, the existiing solution and your proposal convey appear 
> equivalent information, but yours introduces different (note, not 
> 'better) behaviour for a 'just-edited' inset.

If 'not-turning-to-image' is a definite and alarming sign of wrong 
formula, you are right. However, this is not the case. 

1. Correct formula might not be previewed. One simplest example I can 
   think of is: enter a \alpha, wait for preview, copy and paste this 
   alpha. The new one will NOT be previewed unless you enter and leave 
   it.
2. The current indication of wrong formula is 'nothing happens to the 
   formula afterwards'. This is psychologically hard to notice 
   especially when lyx math box is a *normal* status of a formula.
3. previews need a while to appear, people will not wait and see the 
   result. (Even when they wait, most likely: nothing happened yet... 
   lyx is still compiling? instant-preview does not work? Just another 
   not-shown?)

> Forgive me, but I do not see why this is any improvement at all.

I consider this patch as a minor improvement with minimal cost but of 
course you guys are the judges. :-)

-- 
Bo Peng

Reply via email to