Jean-Marc Lasgouttes wrote: > Le 20/10/2015 23:46, Uwe Stöhr a écrit : >> Georg, attached are 2 documents, one created with LyX 2.1. where I used >> the paragraph settings to center, one created with LyX 2.2. You see the >> difference: The Paragraph-alignment added a paragraph of course leading >> to whitespace one doesn't want in boxes.
Thanks, this was the kind of information I was missing. >> That's why I implemented the alignment in LyX 2.2. as non-paragraph via >> \raggedleft etc because a parbox or minibox is already its own paragraph. > > Note that we already do something like that for tabular cells and floats > (see corrected_end and noTrivlistCentering in Paragraph.cpp). It would > be trivial to do that for boxes too (although I'd like to be sure that > it is needed in all cases). > > So solutions would be : > > 1/ trivial: add BOX_CODE to noTrivlistCentering > > 2/ configurable and semi-trivial: add a tag to insetlayout indicating > the kind of alignment that is preferred for a given inset. > > 3/ more configurable: take the above value as a default, but allow to > change it from the paragraph layout dialog. As far as I understand the different boxes, it is possible to determine the wanted behaviour automatically, so 3/ would be overkill IMHO. However, I am pretty sure that the setting would depend on the box parameters, so some research work is still needed. Such a change would be a file format change (since it would change the amount of whitespace of existing documents), however a different one than 489 which we were discussing before. Since nobody indicated interest in working on this so far, and Uwe is abroad again, I think we should postpone this. Unless somebody comes up with new information, or I get a veto by Scott, I will implement solution 2) of my previous message tomorrow, i.e. reverting the alignment handling in InsetBox.cpp (+ the corresponding changes in the enable/disable GUI logic, which I forgot to mention in the previous message). Georg
