Am 18.04.2010 um 00:08 schrieb BH: > On Sat, Apr 17, 2010 at 3:34 PM, Stephan Witt <st.w...@gmx.net> wrote: >> Am 17.04.2010 um 21:02 schrieb BH: >> >>> On Sat, Apr 17, 2010 at 1:45 PM, Stephan Witt <st.w...@gmx.net> wrote: >>>> Hi, >>>> >>>> thinking about the way to go with spell checkers and thesaurus... >>>> >>>> Currently the build on Mac is able to include aspell with a subset of >>>> dictionaries. >>> >>> I've just downloaded your alpha2 build, and it seems to run fine for >>> me, at least mostly. Spellchecking is a bit weird, though: it seems >>> not to recognize any long words. For example, with the splash.lyx doc, >>> it doesn't like "documentation", "introduction", "characteristics", >>> etc. (It also doesn't like DVI or LaTeX, but that's to be expected.) >> >> I don't know what the problem is here. Is this a regression? > > Yes -- I don't see this in the version of LyX I've compiled. The > problem arises for all words > 11 letters long. (Words <= 11 letters > are fine.)
Hmm, you are using the aspell-library from macports? The dictionaries should be equal then. My port contents output is: % port list aspell-dict-en aspell-dict-en @6.0 textproc/aspell-dict-en Port aspell-dict-en contains: % md5 `port contents aspell-dict-en|grep -w local` MD5 (/opt/local/lib/aspell-0.60/en.dat) = ad75814fe4ab93352a4cf6847c0f35b1 MD5 (/opt/local/lib/aspell-0.60/en_affix.dat) = b915c1e0e8ddd76ca9d0abfd39a8d835 MD5 (/opt/local/lib/aspell-0.60/en_phonet.dat) = 1241b381ff5ea57c575c2a8d3d0bacab MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/american-w_accents.alias) = b686e995adafa7218dde9d3f7f9a9da8 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/american-wo_accents.alias) = ce474a5ef5745cda4c457a0139243a0f MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/american.alias) = 6e0be90f50a8017160370f0771c5c458 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ise-w_accents.alias) = 12a7830c7ebf444965f214b686c15b66 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ise-wo_accents.alias) = ed5f7f09433d8ede771178ddd11d3cab MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ise.alias) = 4cbeb1552f361bd17d7b876b1e2ef613 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ize-w_accents.alias) = 17b8d365e532efb46330076e8213f8d2 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ize-wo_accents.alias) = 6621ef3d4d7fb3f5f234220a84cb1a08 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-ize.alias) = 87f1b3cc7c6f0ad42324a06df22d680f MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-w_accents.alias) = 919785f7f7bfe408baecd0bd6893be25 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british-wo_accents.alias) = 39f768ea572c534eec4b8e2b70ac9104 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/british.alias) = 02a0db848317181a696d0002e4ee3109 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/canadian-w_accents.alias) = 0f8c5a265c13e975379eb36ec5192b7a MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/canadian-wo_accents.alias) = 6b3e8e6ef34f8c3c15ba49587ff5ac57 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/canadian.alias) = e6732e58ba939747cc07380e35209ec9 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-common.rws) = ffb7c20150b6b502755c704f0a143fb9 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_0.multi) = a8698b29ca45347816c36fc7fae55a06 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_0.rws) = 9b567a152deabf0e5d20ddef571d746c MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_1.multi) = 72268bf8cf73ccce982cf7a950fd4cd9 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_1.rws) = b597ac679d2150d17ab0745e8b9e41f8 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_2.multi) = 35ba4e2cc6b06c2ac03c0ee6f7b1d8ca MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-variant_2.rws) = 47aa167ad6d42782a6573f9b55c4397e MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-w_accents.multi) = 8a85a13e947ae33254c09dad757bfbcd MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-wo_accents.multi) = 3459daf2b91fc7457ccd0ff628413b6a MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en.multi) = f21d5225cde27bd129857f6811066c29 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_CA-w_accents-only.rws) = eae416b6b7b5957b58c080c5c9204e40 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_CA-w_accents.multi) = d56e314cb9a8ce69e7178bf032aa9a2b MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_CA-wo_accents-only.rws) = db0565c5ad2b4dc292b1817c5b611325 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_CA-wo_accents.multi) = 336a55607eab573951eab8b7c52c2c66 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_CA.multi) = 6b3e8e6ef34f8c3c15ba49587ff5ac57 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ise-w_accents-only.rws) = 0bfdf1dcff35f8b8cea1883af4f506cf MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ise-w_accents.multi) = f53b0ec0b5942e382d19b2fa8543b8cd MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ise-wo_accents-only.rws) = 96c57d24121d2c745d908a7f31308b7d MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ise-wo_accents.multi) = a768e47d4ec1ac038e142b08de46c889 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ise.multi) = ed5f7f09433d8ede771178ddd11d3cab MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ize-w_accents-only.rws) = e9b5ebb26a3342a0cfb0f13d52bd418a MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ize-w_accents.multi) = c4da0a987edc43c1ab121bb0f450bd7a MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ize-wo_accents-only.rws) = b360ebd42c9c43dca45a89d4e92b180e MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ize-wo_accents.multi) = 4db6489f25d5c7223fa9c1cfedfe24c5 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-ize.multi) = 6621ef3d4d7fb3f5f234220a84cb1a08 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-w_accents.multi) = 12a7830c7ebf444965f214b686c15b66 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB-wo_accents.multi) = ed5f7f09433d8ede771178ddd11d3cab MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_GB.multi) = ed5f7f09433d8ede771178ddd11d3cab MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_US-w_accents-only.rws) = 01eae61335e8e8aa06668d2e429aa9e5 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_US-w_accents.multi) = 5362905b3676dc58a84a38b17efadeeb MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_US-wo_accents-only.rws) = 3ab3069710274dc5ccad7a647c8afe2a MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_US-wo_accents.multi) = 794621e1e7e80456c5e43371147f47b7 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en_US.multi) = ce474a5ef5745cda4c457a0139243a0f MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english-variant_0.alias) = 2b12b0caeeee3e110ceb3f41df694ded MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english-variant_1.alias) = 7e5a8b7adc58ab5bd4e5069e3b903599 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english-variant_2.alias) = aafcb6c9d233cb6667410e881eab4641 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english-w_accents.alias) = 80c0c2e766a6a2d9b172b68a233671ad MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english-wo_accents.alias) = f21d5225cde27bd129857f6811066c29 MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/english.alias) = 779dcd460ab85ff3958b8422847f00f7 The distribution is a copy of that: % md5 /opt/local/share/aspell/en-common.rws lyx-build/LyX-2.0.0alpha2.app/Contents/Frameworks/Aspell.framework/Resources/dict/en-common.rws MD5 (/opt/local/share/aspell/en-common.rws) = ffb7c20150b6b502755c704f0a143fb9 MD5 (lyx-build/LyX-2.0.0alpha2.app/Contents/Frameworks/Aspell.framework/Resources/dict/en-common.rws) = ffb7c20150b6b502755c704f0a143fb9 So I'll check the configure options then. > > By the way, when I run your version of LyX from gdb, I get the > following warning: > > warning: Could not find object file > "/Users/stephan/cvs/lyx/aspell-0.60.6/common/.libs/cache.o" - no debug > information available for "common/cache.cpp". I'll investigate this soon. Today I'm not at home anymore. > > repeating many times (for different files). > >>>> I've prepared a patch to allow for searching dictionaries at different >>>> locations. >>>> I'll attach it below. Now LyX/Mac is looking at runtime >>>> 1) in LYX_USERDIR, >>>> 2) included aspell framework and >>>> 3) systems macports installation >>>> until it finds any support for the requested language. >>>> >>>> There are some questions remaining: >>>> * Are the locations of the runtime lookup above sensible? >>>> * Is aspell the best spell checker available? >>>> (At least its the one compiling out of the box on Mac, I failed with >>>> enchant and hunspell) >>> >>> Both enchant and hunspell, installed via macports, work for me with >>> cmake. But what would be best is Apple's spellchecker. (Then we >>> wouldn't have to worry about dictionaries.) >> >> I'm having trouble using macports libraries. They are not working with 10.4 >> SDK and I failed >> to build LyX with configure because of link errors with iconv (some >> incompatibility >> between iconv in /usr/lib and /opt/local/lib. >> >> So I'm using self-compiled qt4 and aspell libraries. But the current source >> distributions >> of hunspell and enchant I couldn't build until now. (Basically I tried >> ./configure ; make only) >> >> Apple's spellchecker provides an C-API as far as I knows. I'll try some >> investigations in the future. >> >>>> >>>> * JMarc asked for some more general way for distributing bundled >>>> dictionaries. >>>> Is there any proposal how to proceed here? >>>> * How to give the user the option to install missing dictionaries on her >>>> own? >>>> The lookup in LYX_USERDIR is only the first step. Should there be some >>>> build-in mechanism >>>> to help installing (aspell)-dictionaries there? >>>> * What is the state of thesaurus support? Can anyone give me some pointer >>>> to documentation >>>> how it should be enabled for Mac? >>> >>> I'm not sure what the problem is. In your alpha2 build, it is enabled >>> (though it is broken at the moment, as was pointed out in another >>> thread). Just point LyX > Preferences > Paths > Thesaurus to the >>> location of the mythes dictionaries (which I have at >>> LYX_USERDIR/thesaurus), and it should work. >> >> The problem is: I don't know how to install and use the mythes dictionaries, >> exactly. >> Is there any documentation at wiki.lyx.org or at some other location? Google >> did not help. > > Grab the mythes source from here: > > http://lingucomponent.openoffice.org/thesaurus.html > > The English dictionaries are included. (That's where I got them.) Not > sure about other languages. Thanks. Stephan
