On 2010-01-13, Pavel Sanda wrote:
> Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote:
>> >doesn't work because of different preambles and different
>> >needs of manuals.
>> >

>> Which I still don't understand.

> http://www.lyx.org/trac/ticket/5460

only repeats this claim:

  to make that work through master/child is painfull due to the different
  demands of the manuals (preamble stuff, etc).

but no further explanation/evidence.

IMO

* Creating a master file does not necessarily interfere with the child
  documents.
  
  All manuals should remain compilable as stand-alone documents.

  Maybe some adjustments would be needed to solve conflicting
  requirements.

* Compiling the master would of course require all the requirements --
  which not everyone has on his/her machine.
  
  However anyone able to compile all manuals should be able to compile
  the master.
  
* Even if compiling the master proves impossible with LaTeX, it might be
  possible to export it to HTML.


If a master file (without changes to the content of current manuals) is
possible, we can decide on using this for cross-links (very helpfull in
HTML and hyperlinked PDF).

Also, while Uwe wrote in a comment to #5460:

  I don't see benefits of a single book as it would then also contain
  duplicate information.
  
I would prefer to replace this duplicate information by navigable
references to a "canonical" place.

Günter

Reply via email to