> and i would add: no individual embedding (like in odf i guess)
>
> (which would probably boil down to something very similar like this:
> http://www.mail-archive.com/lyx-devel@lists.lyx.org/msg138780.html)

Edwin,

I have seen this link a few times, are you sure you want to propose
your idea? We have been called masochists!

Seriously, it seems that you are not going to implement your idea so
you have to convince someone else to do that for you. If nobody is
going to consider your idea and willing to implement it, your idea
will not be implemented, however good it might be. The three proposals
involved in the discussions all have proof-of-concept patches, yet the
discussions have been difficult. I, for one, will not look at your
proposal if there is no patch, or at least a detailed description of
how it works, and why it is better than some of the proposals here. I
am not impolite, I am just do not have time to examine a premature
proposal and figure out all the missing pieces.

Your proposal may be good at the first glance, but the devil is often
in the details. Taking Richard's proposal as an example, it is based
on this very simple 'copy to filename.lyxdir' idea that looks very
appealing. Yet it is challenged for several drawbacks. Are you sure
your proposal can survive such a close look?

No offense, really.

Bo

Reply via email to