Following are 4 (large) patches for support of bidirectional
block I/O in kernel. (not including SCSI-ml or iSCSI)
The submitted work is against linux-2.6-block tree as of
2007/04/15, and will only cleanly apply in succession.
The patches are based on the RFC I sent 3 months ago. They only
cover the block layer at this point. I suggest they get included
in Morton's tree until they reach the kernel so they can get
compiled on all architectures/platforms. There is still a chance
that architectures I did not compile were not fully converted.
(FWIW, my search for use of struct request members failed to find
them). If you find such a case, please send me the file
name and I will fix it ASAP.
Patches summary:
1. [PATCH 1/4] bidi support: request dma_data_direction
- Convert REQ_RW bit flag to a dma_data_direction member like in
SCSI-ml use.
- removed rq_data_dir() and added other APIs for querying request's
direction.
- fix usage of rq_data_dir() and peeking at req->cmd_flags & REQ_RW to
using
new api.
- clean-up bad usage of DMA_BIDIRECTIONAL and bzero of none-queue
requests,
to use the new blk_rq_init_unqueued_req()
2. [PATCH 2/4] bidi support: fix req->cmd == INT cases
- Digging into all these old drivers, I have found traces of past life
where request->cmd was the command type. This patch fixes some of
these
places. All drivers touched by this patch are clear indication of
drivers
that were not used for a while. Should we removed them from Kernel?
These Are:
drivers/acorn/block/fd1772.c, drivers/acorn/block/mfmhd.c,
drivers/block/nbd.c, drivers/cdrom/aztcd.c,
drivers/cdrom/cm206.c
drivers/cdrom/gscd.c, drivers/cdrom/mcdx.c,
drivers/cdrom/optcd.c
drivers/cdrom/sjcd.c, drivers/ide/legacy/hd.c,
drivers/block/amiflop.c
2. [PATCH 3/4] bidi support: request_io_part
- extract io related fields in struct request into struct
request_io_part
in preparation to full bidi support.
- new rq_uni() API to access the sub-structure. (Please read below
comment
on why an API and not open code the access)
- Convert All users to new API.
3. [PATCH 4/4] bidi support: bidirectional block layer
- add one more request_io_part member for bidi support in struct
request.
- add block layer API functions for mapping and accessing bidi data
buffers
and for ending a block request as a whole (end_that_request_block())
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Developer comments:
patch 1/4: Borrow from struct scsi_cmnd use of enum dma_data_direction. Further
work (in
progress) is the removal of the corresponding member from struct scsi_cmnd and
converting
all users to directly access rq_dma_dir(sc->req).
patch 3/4: The reasons for introducing the rq_uni(req) API rather than directly
accessing
req->uni are:
* WARN(!bidi_dir(req)) is life saving when developing bidi enabled paths. Once
we, bidi
users, start to push bidi requests down the kernel paths, we immediately get
warned of
paths we did not anticipate. Otherwise, they will be very hard to find, and
will hurt
kernel stability.
* A cleaner and saner future implementation could be in/out members rather than
uni/bidi_read. This way the dma_direction member can deprecated and the uni
sub-
structure can be maintained using a pointer in struct req.
With this API we are free to change the implementation in the future without
touching any users of the API. We can also experiment with what's best. Also,
with the
API it is much easier to convert uni-directional drivers for bidi (look in
ll_rw_block.c in patch 4/4).
* Note, that internal uses inside the block layer access req->uni directly, as
they will
need to be changed if the implementation of req->{uni, bidi_read} changes.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-scsi" in
the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
