> If they all point to the same space, I can't tell whether I have three > legacy spaces or one. I need to know how many legacy spaces there are > in order to know how many VGA cards can simultaneously be enabled.
You don't need to care about this, at least in userland. All you need is proper primitives for locking/unlocking access to a given device. Wether you have another one to arbitrate with on the same PCI bus or not is almost irrelevant. That is, it is the job of the kernel driver that ultimately will do this arbitration (we really need that), and we can prefectly well survive a long time with a very simple implementation taht always disable all other VGA devies in the system, not caring about "simultaneous" access. That implementation can be then improved on later. My point is what we really need to define is the in-kernel and userland API to do this basic VGA access arbitration in the first place. I though you did something like that a while ago Jon, didn't you ? I think it could be as simple as an additional sysfs entry "legacy_enabled" added to all "VGA" devices in the system at the PCI layer level. Toggling it triggers the "untoggling" of all others, including VGA forwarding on bridges, and enables the path to that device. For in-kernel users, a pci_* API would work. The problem I see though is that it should all be synchronous & spinlocked since the vgacon could want to grab at interrupt time (unless it's locked by userland, in which case, vgacon should cache & trigger an update later). Ben. - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED] More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
