On Wednesday 03 October 2007, you wrote:
> Follow up - the OpenU recently published a pre-proposal for the project:
>
> See http://telem.openu.ac.il/resources/files/proposal.pdf
>

Item 4.2(2) says, very emphatically, that the books must be published in 
an "open and free" (no definition of 'free' given) format, with all their 
features accessible from at least IE6 and FF2 on Windows, Linux and OSX using 
free software.

Sounds great. But then 4.2(10), entitled 'DRM', requires DRM that will block 
printing more than a page at once and saving local copies.

Surely they must be aware that this combination of requirements is kind of 
pointless? This looks like people with very different ideas came to a weird 
compromise. 

BTW, item 5 says the books 'are and will remain under OU copyright'. That's 
all there is on the subject of licensing, but given the stated goals of not 
allowing things like saving local copies, and since the site will require 
registration for access (item 4.1(8)), I imagine there will be a click 
through usage agreement where users will also agree not to do these things.

Why is the OU interested in imposing these kinds of limitations? I would 
really like to know. It's a university, it has already decided to publish 
these books online free as beer for all comers. What else is there but to let 
people use the books in the most efficient and convenient ways they can think 
of?

-- 
Dan Armak

=================================================================
To unsubscribe, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with
the word "unsubscribe" in the message body, e.g., run the command
echo unsubscribe | mail [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to