Debconf13 (last week) considered the matter of bare-metal cross-toolchains in Debian. Ideally we would have one toolchain source package from which the existing linux native compilers, and cross-compilers are built, including bare-metal cross-compilers. There is already mechanism for adding patches for particular gcc builds, so so long as the patch set is manageable and trackable, this would be nice, and futureproof, as eventually the patch set should just evaporate as it gets upstreamed.
The alternative it to simply repack the existing linaro cross-toolchain sources, but them we get to keep doing that for new releases, and we have gratuitous extra copies of gcc sources and corresponding differences between A* and M* toolchains/versions. The linaro embedded toolchains (https://launchpad.net/gcc-arm-embedded/4.7/4.7-2013-q1-update) are good, and work, both for M0 and M3. But building nominally the same thing from upstream gcc gets something where M3 works but M0 doesn't. Also they are gcc 4.7 based whilst Debian is moving to a 4.8 default. We peered at checkouts from linaro and upstream and tried to work out what the linaro patch-set for this toolchain is, and exactly where it branched off upstream, but it was confusing with a lot of noise due to version skew around some actually relevant changes. So, in order to work out if we can in fact build our bare-metal toolchains from the same sources as the existing toolchains we need to know what the actual patch-set you are maitaining looks like, and what is already upstreamed in which gcc branch/release and when the remaining patches will go upstream. Also what the 4.7 vs 4.8 status is. Knowing how this stuff is tracked might be even more useful over the longer term. Is there such info online somewhere? If not please elaborate. A mechanism for keeping the (newly-formed) Debian cross-compiler team sufficiently in the loop is probably what's needed in the longer term, unless this is all just about to get upstreamed anyway and the issue will soon become moot...? There was also discussion around the concept of making existing linux-arm cross-compilers, with M0 and M3 support included, and using spec-file jiggery-pokery to get them to DTRT for M* targets. This should be possible, but advice from anyone who's every actually tried on the gotchas would be good. cheers Wookey -- Principal hats: Linaro, Emdebian, Wookware, Balloonboard, ARM http://wookware.org/ _______________________________________________ linaro-dev mailing list linaro-dev@lists.linaro.org http://lists.linaro.org/mailman/listinfo/linaro-dev
