Hello, knowing that it has been discussed before, I want nevertheless express my interest in another exchange format than midi: ly to musicxml
I have been working more than 6 years with Finale and switched to Lilypond several months ago. (See my contributions to Mutopia). There is really one thing I miss: A decend midi interpretation of the music with control not only over the melody but also the articulations and expressions. In the moment my main tool is Finale with *Robert* Piéchauds Human Playback and GPO (Garritans Personal Orchestra), JABB and the Gofriller. So what I do: 1. Write the LilyPond code 2. Produce a PDF-File 3. Use PDFtoMusic from Myriad to produce a Harmony Assistant file 4. With Harmony Assistant a produce a music-xml file 5. I load this file into Finale to produce a midifile where most of the musical expressions are interpreted 6. When I am in the mood I use a DAW to tune things up 7. Last but not least I can hear the music But you can imagine what gets lost and added to the original .ly file during theses transformations. Sometimes it is not useable and I have no desire to rewrite the score in Finale. Of course Lilyponds target is to produce highly readable musical notation. And it does this job perfectly wonderful. But it would be really a pitty if this would be the end of the road. We have all the tools to use the score to make real audible music. So some kind of help to make this process easier would be helpfull. Hajo -- --- ... indessen wandelt harmlos droben das Gestirn
_______________________________________________ lilypond-user mailing list lilypond-user@gnu.org http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
