For what it's worth, I think the original suggestion (with the top-left
clef adjusted by -4.4%) is the better of the two.
I do understand that there's an argument to be made against adjusting
clefs that aren't /too/ bad, but the adjusted versions of the treble
clefs /are/ better imo.
With aesthetics and readability being important reasons why Lilypond is
superior to other music typesetters, I think this adjustment is just
splendid!
Best wishes,
Jakob
On 09.12.2023 12.40, Michael Gerdau wrote:
Thanks, but I would like to know whether you prefer the top
(alto-based) or bottom (treble-based) image on
https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/2188
Top (alto-based) is 6 days ago and bottom (treble-based) is 4 days ago as of
today?
Of those two I prefer bottom as it seems to be more balanced overall to me.
Kind regards,
Michael
