On 10/4/2019 8:23 AM, list_lilyp...@infopower.nl wrote:
Hello all,
(very) long time not been here.
I'm engraving some drum scores for kids and it seems their teacher is
using another notation standard than Lilypond, zo I looked it up on
wikipedia ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Percussion_notation ) and it
seems indeed that there are two 'standards' for percussion notation.
One apparently less used from Peckman, Jonathan (2007) (Picture
Yourself Drumming, p.46. ISBN 1-59863-330-9), and one based on the
recommendations of the Percussive Arts Society found in Norman
Weinberg’s Guide To Standardized Drumset Notation (2002, ISBN
0-9664928-1-1).
(I'm just copying here from wikipedia.)
It seems Lilypond uses neither one, as shown by the hi-hat which it
positions between the 4th and 5th staff line, whereas both wikipedia
examples, *and* the kids' teacher, position the hi-hat a half line
higher (on the 5th line).
My question is now which standard Lilypond is using and why, and is it
authoritative enough to try to bugger the teacher into switching to
it? (I don't really mean to bugger him, rather some kind of trying to
convince him that it's better for the kids to learn a notation 'that
everyone is using'.)
If those 3 standards are all acceptable, wouldn't it be better if a
Lilipond engraver were able to choose which standard to use in his piece?
Thanks for your thoughts!
Hello,
I don't know much about the history of LilyPond's percussion "standard"
but could you do something like this to configure it how you wish? Make
this as "modern" as you'd like? :) I've never had to do this but I
remember saving it from a while back...
#(define moderndrums '(
(acousticbassdrum () #f -3)
(bassdrum () #f -3)
(sidestick cross #f 1)
(acousticsnare () #f 1)
(snare () #f 1)
(handclap triangle #f 1)
(electricsnare () #f 1)
(lowfloortom () #f -4)
(closedhihat cross "stopped" 5)
(hihat cross #f 5)
(highfloortom () #f -1)
(pedalhihat cross #f -5)
(lowtom () #f 2)
(openhihat cross "open" 5)
(halfopenhihat xcircle #f 5)
(lowmidtom () #f 2)
(himidtom () #f 3)
(crashcymbala cross #f 7)
(crashcymbal cross #f 7)
(hightom () #f 3)
(ridecymbala cross #f 4)
(ridecymbal cross #f 6)
(chinesecymbal xcircle #f 6)
(ridebell () #f 6)
(splashcymbal cross #f 9)
(cowbell triangle #f 5)
(crashcymbalb cross #f 8)
(vibraslap diamond #f 4)
(ridecymbalb cross #f 5)
))
_______________________________________________
lilypond-user mailing list
lilypond-user@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user
