On 11.12.24 02:13, Dan Eble wrote:
Current Name                    Proposed New Name
    ------------------------------  ---------------------------
    measureLength                   measureLength (no change)
    minimumPageTurnLength           pageTurnMinimumRestLength
    minimumRepeatLengthForPageTurn  pageTurnMinimumRepeatLength

Very much an improvement!

proportionalNotationDuration    (not sure yet)

Brainstorming: proportionalNotationBase – proportionalNotationShortest – proportionalNotationShortestNote – proportionalNotationBaseMoment (yes, I know…) – proportionalShortestNote

tupletSpannerDuration           tupletBracketMusicalLength
    voltaSpannerDuration            voltaBracketMusicalLength

Seems awkward to me to use Length. Less awkward to use MusicLength, because the user will know to use \musicLength (which is no problem as a name) for producing the value. I see that the grob property of VoltaBracket is called musical-length, though…

Since context property voltaSpannerDuration is deprecated anyway, maybe delete it? For how long has it been deprecated? Maybe rename grob property musical-length so users don’t get confused about musical-length = \musicLength 4 ? Spelling it out, doesn’t seem actually confusing to me. Don’t have time to continue thinking about that, right now.

Best, Simon


The motivation for moving away from "duration" is that there is an internal type called duration and that is not what these use.

There is inconsistency between "length" and "musical length" because it sounds unnecessary to specify that "length" is used in the musical sense for measure, rest, or repeat, but it seems helpful to specify it for a horizontal bracket.

Do you agree?

--
–––––––––––––––––
Kirchbergstraße 25
74348 Lauffen
Festnetz (Büro, Zeiten unregelmäßig) +49 (0)7133 900 28 61
Mobil +49 (0)155 66 48 1379


Reply via email to