All, >> Phil, whatever you can offer to help. I know nothing about Ancient music >> typesetting and was just basing my additions on what was already in the >> NR. I had asked a few years ago for some help with the Ancient music NR >> section
oh, sorry, I missed it. I'm glad to help (I guess that would mainly be explaining things about ancient notation). >> as it really is looking rather odd and has not had any of the >> tidying up work that I did with Graham all those years ago because only >> a few people knew enough to know what was wrong or could be improved. >> >> I assumed (incorrectly as it turned out) that the #'mensural value was >> generic for all ancient music types and that it was the clef >> name/settings that made the output 'Gregorian' vs 'Mensural'. :) It's the notehead style: vaticana, medicaea, solesmes and hufnagel are for gregorian, mensural, neomensural and petrucci for mensural music. I'm not at all sure about kievan -- it seems mensural, but I may well be mistaken. >> Although there are a lot of diffs, they are mainly just cut/paste edits >> so if you can give me some broad education on what values I need to use >> for a given set of keys sigs that should be enough than you go through >> every single edit line by line. >> I ordered the clefs as they appeared in the scm file rather than any >> alphabetical or notational style order. I think that's a good order. >> I figured it would be easier to >> correct someone's work than get a developer to do the edits themselves, >> so have at it, let me know what I need to change. >> >> To save you (and anyone else who may want to help) you can download what >> the table looks like when it is compiled from here: >> >> https://cloud.woelkli.com/s/dBGXat0NEGVoy5C >> >> This is just that Clef section in the appendix so it is a small PDF. Grouping and ordering is fine. >> Otherwise tell me what I need to fix or what is not correct etc. >> >> If you think removing notes would be better (in this appendix) then I >> can simply use 'spacers' (or if lilypond-book allows it, nothing at >> all). >> >> James > > > I'll have a look at sending you some suggested changes tomorrow - I'm in all > day so this will be something to work on. > > I think the notes add some value, since they show where middle C is with the > relevant clef. Agreed. p _______________________________________________ lilypond-devel mailing list lilypond-devel@gnu.org https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
