2011/6/13 <tdanielsmu...@googlemail.com>:
> Thanks - much clearer!
>
> Two points:
>
> a) It would be better to honour the value of 'gap if this
> is set by the user, rather than change a specifically
> requested gap value.
My rationale is that it wouldn't make sense to set a big gap and
really want to have it applied to all ambituses. Consider the
following:
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
c' g'
}
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
c' a'
}
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
c' b'
}
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
c' c''
}
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
c' e''
}
\new Staff \with { \consists Ambitus_engraver } {
\override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.7
a a''
}
While gap=0.7 works fine for big ambituses (one can easily imagine
that a user may wish such a value), the ambitus of sixth looks
ridiculous without any line inside. I suppose that if someone would
like that "look", he would probably switch the line off entirely.
And for small gap the effect is almost unnoticeable.
> b) I don't understand why quanting is desired. An ambitus
> doesn't align with anything. What is your reason?
I thought that it's best if ambitus line eihter ends precisely inside
staff line, or protrudes from it distinctly. In other words, i judged
that
\new Staff \with { \consists "Ambitus_engraver" }
{ \override Staff.AmbitusLine #'gap = #0.3 c' b' }
doesn't look nice.
Ofc i'm aware that this is perhaps as nitpicky as it can go :D
Thanks,
Janek
_______________________________________________
lilypond-devel mailing list
lilypond-devel@gnu.org
https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
