Ken Bates' favourite film is The Producers. He's a real life Max Bialystock.


Nigel.


On 9 April 2014 19:34, John Boocock <[email protected]> wrote:

>
>
>
> Sent in great haste from a mobile phone
>
> -------- Original message --------
> From: Leeds United Supporters Trust <[email protected]>
> Date: 09/04/2014  18:27  (GMT+00:00)
> To: John <[email protected]>
> Subject: Trust financial analysis of LUFC account 2013
>
> Leeds United Supporters Trust Statement
> Is this email not displaying correctly?
> View it in your browser.
>
> Trust financial analysis of LUFC account 2013
> FINANCE UPDATE - 2013
> Now that the latest accounts (to June 2013) have finally landed we have
> undertaken a review and have the following summary for our members.
>
> HEADLINES
> - Turnover decreased by 8% from £31.1m to £28.6m (compared to 4% in
> 2011/12)
> - Gate receipts decreased by 17% from £11.3m to £9.7m (compared to 12% in
> 2011/12) with average attendance down by 7.7% - perhaps reflecting lower
> ticket prices as a factor
> - Staff costs to turnover ratio increased from 57% to 70% (51% in 2010/11)
> - Overall admin costs increased from £9.8m to £13.3m (£8.6m in 2010/11)
> - "Unknown" admin costs increased from £5.2m to £6.2m (£4.5m in 2010/11)
> - Directors received £794k compared to £347k in 2011/12, with one director
> awarded a £440k bonus.
> - Yorkshire Radio has had an impact of £1.5m on the loss in the year as
> LUFC have been forced to write off all the amounts they were owed by them.
> - Profits from net player trading of £2.0m helped reduce the overall loss
> from £11.6m to £9.6m.
> - The current debt stands at £24.7m compared to £14.6m on a like for like
> basis 1 year ago
> - Money gained from the court case win against WYP (of £1m) was put
> towards clearing payments of the preference shares - controlled by Ken Bates
>
> These accounts show the situation at Leeds United as at the end of June
> 2013 which was before the widely reported further funding that has been
> injected into the club by Cellino, so in all likelihood the debt has grown
> since.
>
> Despite what has been claimed, GFH have actually invested nothing into
> Leeds United but have instead loaded further debt onto the club and managed
> to record the biggest annual loss since 2004 (the immediate post-Ridsdale
> era).
>
> While Ken Bates and Shaun Harvey were in control for 50% of this period
> and undoubtedly laid the foundations for the performance in areas such as
> the decreased gate receipts, it is only during the second half of the year
> that we see the debt escalating at a pace, which would suggest that this is
> when the costs started to spiral. As we have stated in the past, it was
> always our view that performance was going to be worse in 2012/13 (had the
> old regime remained in place) than the season before it, but even we are
> shocked at just how dramatically it has deteriorated.
>
> Summary of Leeds United Football Club Limited Numbers
> Excluding Player Trading
>
>
>         2013    2012    Variance        Variance
>         £'000   £'000   £'000   %
> Turnover        28,568  31,080  (2,512) (8%)
> Cost of Sales   (5,558) (5,582) (24)    0%
> Admin Exps      (33,304)        (27,672)        (5,632) 20%
> Operating Profit/(Loss) (10,294)        (2,174) (8,120) (374%)
>
> Staff Costs     20,004  17,828  2,176   12%
> Other Admin*    13,300  9,844   3,456   35%
>
> *Includes:
> Rent    1,893   1,861   32      2%
> Depreciation    1,477   1,193   284     24%
> Accountancy Fees        140     112     28      20%
> Other Known     3,570   1,444   2,126   148%
> Unknown 6,220   5,234   986     19%
> Post Administration Figures for Leeds City Holdings (Excluding Player
> Trading)
>
> 2013
> 2012
> 2011
> 2010
> 2009
> 2008
>         £'000   £'000   £'000   £'000   £'000   £'000
> Turnover        29,322  33,097  34,475  27,533  23,535  23,249
> Cost of Sales   (6,190) (6,559) (6,376) (5,883) (4.930) (4.166)
> Admin Exps      (33,760)        (29,557)        (26,486)        (22,789)
>      (21,384)        (18,217)
> Operating Profit/(Loss) (10,628)        (3,019) 1,613   (1,139) (2,779) 866
>                                                 14 months
> Turnover
> Turnover has steadily declined since its peak under the Bates Regime back
> in 2011/12 season, as some fans decided to vote with their feet in order to
> protest against the running of the club. This meant that we were always
> expecting a fall this season as GFH were tasked with trying to repair the
> relationship with the fans. Gate receipts fell 17% and account for £1.6m of
> the £8.1m increase in losses during the season. Unsurprisingly
> merchandising fell by a similar percentage (and added a further £875k to
> the deficit); the remainder of the Turnover items (TV revenue, Central
> distribution and Commercial activities) more or less netted out meaning
> that total decrease in Turnover accounted for £2.5m of the overall increase
> in losses.
>
> Wages to Turnover
> While turnover decreased, the badly needed investment in the playing squad
> did happen. However, the figures suggest that it was more of an investment
> in total number of playing staff rather than an increase in quality. The
> overall squad grew from 46 playing staff (including apprentices) to 58
> during the year (a 26% increase). Overall wages increased by 12% in
> comparison; there was some reduction in other staff, but given that the
> largest part of the wage bill relates to Playing staff and management
> (which also increased from 17 to 20 people), it seems safe to assume that
> the average amount paid to the playing staff actually decreased.
>
> While we have always called for an increase in the wages to turnover
> ratio, the method under which this has been achieved during the year in
> question is not really what we had in mind. With turnover down (by £2.5m)
> and the number of playing and management staff increasing dramatically (at
> an additional cost of £2.2m), the ratio went from 57% to 70%. It is highly
> unlikely that Leeds United will have the lowest ratio in the division
> anymore but, while the quantity side of this equation has been fulfilled,
> the quality of the additional spending does not seem to have noticeably
> improved. We would not call for this ratio to be exceeded next season (or
> beyond), in fact if anything it needs to decrease, but we would definitely
> suggest to the new management that a reduction in quantity and increase in
> quality needs to be the focus.
>
> Costs of the Directors has increased dramatically which can largely be
> explained by the increase in number of Directors, as well as the
> significant bonus payment made to one of them (£440k).
>
> Other Costs
> It is this area where we have seen the most shocking situation. We have
> always maintained that the 'other' costs at Leeds United were excessive,
> therefore to see a £3.4m increase in these was deeply concerning. In terms
> of the increase, we can see that £1.5m of this relates to a one-off cost
> associated with the closure of Yorkshire Radio (where the debt owed to
> Leeds United by the radio station had to be written off), a further £0.6m
> relates to increased admin costs associated with player transfers and £0.3m
> relates to the legacy of Bates building works. The remaining £1m of
> additional costs is unknown, taking what was already a bewildering £5.2m
> figure up to £6.2m. Undoubtedly much of these are likely to be legal costs
> associated with the takeover but it seems any hope of light being shed on
> these unknown expenses under the regime of GFH has been disappointingly
> shattered.
>
> We still believe this is an area Massimo Cellino can find savings in and
> hope that it will go some way to reducing future losses.
>
> Cash
> As we expected cash has been in short supply at Elland Road, and this
> became even more apparent with the recent reports of a wages crisis at the
> club. Given the huge increase in costs and the reduction in revenues this
> is no surprise, but it is obviously a situation that cannot be sustained.
> Just how close we came to another Administration event may never come to
> light but the accounts reflect a situation where the club was living a hand
> to mouth existence for some time and this situation would have had to come
> to a head but for the introduction of a new cash injection.
>
> Group Companies
> The Group situation is perhaps the one area where it appears that GFH took
> the painful decisions and acted correctly. Yorkshire Radio was closed down
> having made further losses (which impacted the football operations) and
> some consolidation appears to have occurred making the family a bit more
> manageable in size. However, the eternal promise made by Ken Bates
> regarding non matchday incomes has still yet to materialise as the combined
> efforts of the non footballing side of things resulted in a turnover of
> £754k and costs of £1.09m (an overall loss of £334k).
>
> Debts
> In six months GFH appear to have added a further £10m (net) to the debt
> left behind by Ken Bates, much of which is in the form of short term loans.
> The list below details the current situation regarding debts at the club.
>
> Preference Share payment to Lutonville  £0.1m
> Ticketus 2 LLP Loan Repayment   £2.3m
> Compass £1.3m
> Brendale        £11.3m
> Berrydale       £2.0m
> Director Bonus  £0.2m
> Sport Capital   £1.8m
> Working Capital Shortfall       £5.7m
> TOTAL DEBT      £24.7m
> If the contingent payment of £4.8m to the Administrators is included this
> figure increases to £29.5m (assuming we get promoted by 2018).
>
> Conclusion
> If we thought when we parted company with Ken Bates that things could not
> get any worse, that has quickly been dispelled by these numbers. This does
> not mean that Ken was in anyway better for the club, nor is he absolved
> from blame in our opinion. Many of the issues relate directly to the state
> of the club that he handed over (falling revenues, disgruntled fans) and
> the long term decisions he took (Yorkshire Radio and the building
> obsession), but what is clear is that GFH did not seem equipped to manage
> these situations and had no obvious plan to do it. They took over the club
> with no funding and have had to react to each cash crisis as it arose by
> finding loans as and where they could. It seems obvious why they needed so
> desperately to sell. However, perhaps the profitable running of the club
> was never a real concern, as the GFH financial statements appear to show
> that in spite of all this they have managed to make a profit out of this
> sorry state of affairs. GFH reported that they made a US$6m profit out of
> their holding in Leeds United by selling shares in the club (Leeds United
> Holdings) to strategic investors. Like Leeds United, those investors seem
> not to have been quite as fortunate as GFH in terms of profit as reports
> suggest the club has been sold to Massimo Cellino at a value nearer to what
> they originally paid.
>
> As is always the case finances never tell the full story but, while GFH do
> not appear to be able to run a profitable club, they do seem to be able to
> make a profit out of a loss making enterprise.
>
>
> -----------------
>
> Supporters can also join more than 9,000 other Leeds fans and have their
> voice heard as members of the Leeds United Supporters' Trust by filling in
> the form at www.lufctrust.org. Membership is free. Keep checking for
> updates on www.lufctrust.org, and our Facebook and Twitter pages.
>
>  follow on Twitter | L.U.S.T on Facebook | forward to a friend
> Copyright (c) 2014 Leeds United Supporters Trust, All rights reserved.
> You are receiving this message because you are a registered Leeds United
> Supporters' Trust shareholder
> Our mailing address is:
> Leeds United Supporters Trust
> 35 Copley Hall Terrace
> Copley, West Yorkshire HX3 0TS
> United Kingdom
>
> Add us to your address book
>
>  unsubscribe from this list | update subscription preferences
>
> _______________________________________________
> Leedslist mailing list
> Info and options:
> http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
> To unsubscribe, email [email protected]
>
> John 'Grampa' Sykes
> Rest In Peace old lad
> 28th Oct 1938 - 12 Nov 2013
> MARCHING ON TOGETHER
>



-- 
  vectoria.co.uk
     concentrichron.com
--

Mindbrix -- Dream it, draw it, build it, love it

   69 Derby Street
   Beeston
   Nottingham
   NG9 2LG

+44 7905 311 352
  [email protected]
    www.mindbrix.co.uk
      Skype: ntbarber
        twitter.com/mindbrix
_______________________________________________
Leedslist mailing list
Info and options: http://mailman.greennet.org.uk/mailman/listinfo/leedslist
To unsubscribe, email [email protected]

John 'Grampa' Sykes
Rest In Peace old lad
28th Oct 1938 - 12 Nov 2013
MARCHING ON TOGETHER

Reply via email to