Hi Jose,

Yes, a turbo is magical at creating torque! Oh ok, there is nothing magical 
about it....  

Obvisously, there are many different ways to run a turbocharged engine. If we 
are talking about normalization and/or very slight boost, a turbo'd engine will 
provide more "output" that a non-turbo'd engine for any given useable RPM. 
However; that is a gross oversimplification (with lots of assumptions) so not 
worth much.

My position on your original question is that there are a few people who have a 
great deal of experience and this tends to make their "guesses/estimates" more 
accurate. However; there are many, many people just making wild guesses 
(homebuilders, marketing folks, conversion companies, etc...). Because of this, 
I don't believe anyone until I see dyno numbers.  

The ACCURATE recording of aicraft/engine performance and comparison to similar 
aircraft seems to be a reasonable basis for comparison of power. However; every 
(homebuilt) airplane is different  so this is only a "ball parking" excercise 
in my opinion. Additionally, you are usually comparing to another aircraft with 
an engine who's output has never actually been measured so the whole excercise 
is questionable.  Another "ball parking" tool is accurate recording of fuel 
burn.

I admit, I live in a world of absolutes and precision - not everyone sees the 
world this way.  In short, when someone tells me that their engine produces 84 
hp but cannot produce a dyno sheet and/or tell me under what conditions it 
produces that power, I do not believe them (it may be more or it may be less).

Jon





-----Original Message-----
From: "Jose Fuentes" <jose.fuen...@gmail.com>
Sent: Sunday, December 26, 2010 7:24am
To: "KRnet" <kr...@mylist.net>
Subject: Re: KR> VW True HP

Thanks Mark,

Tell me, with a direct drive 2400cc VW motor, does a turbo have any effect
on HP at prop speed?

Joe

Reply via email to