Jon,

It occurred to me that although the KR wing planform may not be perfect, 
there's certainly nothing badly wrong with it or it's stall characteristics 
that should keep anybody from forging ahead and getting a KR built and in 
the air.  It might be past the point of diminishing returns to try to 
improve on it a lot.  The "new" KR airfoil (the AS504x series)  created by 
graduate student PhD Ashok Gopalarathnam was thoroughly evaluated for stall 
characteristics during the redesign.  This airfoil was specifically designed 
for this airplane, and not many homebuilders have this luxury.  His charter 
was that lift coefficient and pitching moment not be degraded, and that 
stall characteristics didn't suffer.  Past experience by a LOT of KR pilots 
have not revealed a real problem with either the stock airfoil or the new 
one.

That's not to say that the wing planform can't be improved on, just that it 
might not be worth the trouble to "fix it".  I fully understand if you enjoy 
a good challenge and view it as an opportunity to get the cobwebs out and 
review some aero knowledge, make another incremental improvement to the 
breed, and are not in a hurry to get in the air.  But for those builders in 
their 60's, 70's, and 80's, they have no reason to slow down and wait for 
developments.  As William Wynne says, "every day you find something to do 
other than building your airplane is another day closer to losing your 
medical"!  Having said that, I've certainly done my share of that stuff.

While I'm on my soapbox, anyone building a new KR should go straight to the 
AS504x series, rather than using the RAF48 provided with the plans.  This 
new airfoil has been thoroughly tested with good results, and the only real 
difference is the shape of the airfoil, not the wing structure or anything 
else.  There are no "gotchas" hiding in this airfoil.  It's the elusive free 
lunch.  See http://www.krnet.org/as504x/ for details and free airfoil 
template downloads.  It's a no-brainer, and I have no personal monetary gain 
to make from "selling" this airfoil as opposed to the RAF48....

Mark Langford
ML at N56ML.com
website at http://www.N56ML.com
--------------------------------------------------------


Reply via email to