https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=475077

--- Comment #41 from breakingsp...@gmail.com ---
I actually feel like the current three-state Overview-Grid is the best
implementation so far, sans the lack of Desktop Bar. It's more unified than
ever, and the Desktop Grid and Overview can still function independently from
each other. 
But then there are odd issues like this, where the single-screen Overview seems
broken because of a grid row setting. Now it's just a form of "Present Windows"
again, as mentioned before. 

I'd like to add a few more details regarding my use case, same KDE settings
across several machines, 4 virtual desktops in a 2x2 grid, named and kept
distinct from each other. 

For work, i'll use a specific desktop for the types of tickets I work
(frontend, backend, ops), and the top left quadrant is just "Main". When I want
to switch desktops, i'll engage the full Desktop Grid so I can see a general
spread of all windows, with how much work I have in each dept. 

However, I often used Overview on the "Main" desktop once it was a feature, to
show me all windows with the intention of sorting and "flicking" windows to
other desktops via the Desktop Bar (very much like Mac OS and rather
intuitive). If I opened a backend ticket on the frontend desktop, i'd just
flick it to the backend desktop and then single click to focus that desktop
rather than engaging the grid. The search filter is very useful as well. Mac OS
will hide their Desktop bar until you gesture over it, so the always-on bar in
Plasma 5 with a search box blew that out of the water. 

Since Plasma 6, i've found myself unlearning this workflow because of the lack
of this Desktop Bar in the Overview screen (which I assumed was a break), and
instead just engaging the large grid, and flicking windows there in the
exploded view. This works but not near as intuitive and up-close as the
Overview, and I know it's a counterproductive to say, but... it worked before. 

I feel that the Overview should always present a linear Desktop Bar of all
Virtual Desktops, regardless of any Virtual Desktop layout or Desktop Grid
configuration. Even better would be a KCM settings option to hide the bar or
present it from the left side, it should be user preference rather than
determined dynamically.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to