https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=465497

--- Comment #2 from Jakob Petsovits <j.acco...@petsovits.com> ---
Ctrl+F is indeed the standard searching shortcut. However, there is a
difference between searching in a document or "active view", and navigating to
a different location.

If I use Ctrl+F in a web browser, I get the inline search field that searches
the current web page, rather than DuckDuckGo search results. If I use Ctrl+F in
Dolphin, it looks for files in the current directory, rather than taking me to
the location field.

If I use Ctrl+L in a web browser, it takes me to the location field which is
conveniently also a search field for my default search engine. Ctrl+K to the
dedicated search field for people who have both as distinct fields. If I use
Ctrl+L in Dolphin, it takes me to the location bar to allow navigating outside
the current directory by typing a path.

The search field in System Settings is sort of two in one. It searches both KCM
names and KCM contents. If I want to find a particular setting, I'll think
Ctrl+F, although my default assumption would be that this only works within the
current page because that's what Ctrl+F is commonly used for. If I want to find
a particular page, I'll think Ctrl+L or Ctrl+K. The search bar in System
Settings is its location bar, allowing to navigate to a particular page.

This is why Ctrl+F is not intuitive for me. Although perhaps the solution would
be to simply set Ctrl+L and perhaps also Ctrl+K in addition to the default
Ctrl+F shortcut. Then people who associate Ctrl+F with the search bar will
still be happy, and people who associate Ctrl+L or Ctrl+K with the "location
bar" will also be happy. I guess I can open a different bug for that though,
so, not reopening.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to