https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=317299
--- Comment #19 from Piotr Mierzwinski <piotr.mierzwin...@gmail.com> ---
(In reply to Igor Kushnir from comment #18)
> (In reply to Piotr Mierzwinski from comment #17)
> > Just found the issue, where your suggestion about skipping formatting
> > doesn't work how we expected.
> > Namely, in case of 'Adapt signature', where I supposed that formatting is
> > applied automatically I wanted to skip it so I set kdev_format_source
> > without linked file. And unfortunately formatting happened partially. I mean
> > that in this case indicator of reference or pointer was moved next to type,
> > if originally was present next to name of argument.
> > I made test with updating definition of method and in declaration these
> > indicators were modified, but space didn't touch.
> I suppose this is exactly what I surmised in an earlier comment:
> > In case when more code is generated, KDevelop must ensure
> > that it is not formatted in some fixed-for-all-IDE-users style chosen by
> > KDevelop
> > developers, but in the style the user selected for the current
> > session/project.
> Probably KDevelop generates new code for your signature in a predefined
> hard-coded style, then tries to format it in your chosen style and fails,
> leaving the signature in the hard-coded style. Please try to configure
> Artistic Style, uncrustify, clang-format or kdev_format_source to match your
> code formatting as I suggested in my long comment above. See if KDevelop's
> formatting matches your expectations then. Or is your code formatted so
> heterogeneously and unsystematically that even fine-grained
> kdev_format_source configuration is very time-consuming/impossible?
Recently discovered another case where was applied any formatting for 'Adapt
signature' when I had kdev_format_source without linked file
Anyway. I will try to configure some formatting tool and will link it to
KDevelop. My code is formatted rather systematically, I tried to keep one style
in whole code. My style is similar to Artistic Style->Qt only I prefer spaces
in decl.and def., which more or less looks like that:
QMap <QString, QStringList> myFoo2( int p, int &r );
int & myFoo1( bool &res, int b, char *c )
{
int a = 1;
char *res = nullptr;
int *r2;
char tab[5];
if (a > b)
myFoo2(b, r2);
else {
doSomething(c, b, res);
return res;
}
return r2;
}
Note. This code doesn't make sense, it's only example.
Thanks a lot for advice.
--
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.
