https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=413125

--- Comment #4 from vanyossi <ghe...@gmail.com> ---
Created attachment 123448
  --> https://bugs.kde.org/attachment.cgi?id=123448&action=edit
Alpha to color effect

Logic tells me you are right, it should only affect the alpha channel, but In
reality as we make a color more transprent it looses saturation to the white
below. I don't know how is implemented in gimp 2.10 but it gives me the same
results.

Attached image is from gimp Color to alpha. the first two panels I applied 
Color to alpha, then converted the alpha from the channel directly into a
transparency mask: The first one has the mask turned off, the second one has
mask on (in the first on e you see black on fully transparent colors) There is
loss in color. The third and last panel: after applying color to alpha I made a
selection from that alpha information and applied it as an transparency mask to
the original image. The third is with the transparency mask on, and the last
one with the transparency mask off (Here we only affect the alpha but we also
see loss of color).

Doing the exact same in Krita will yield the same results. Color to Alpha ->
Split Alpha -> Alpha into Mask. For the second: Color to Alpha -> Ctrl + Click
on layer thumbnail (or Select -> Select Opaque) -> right click on layer: Add
Transparency Mask.

However in Krita the preview does seem to shift color. This seems to happen as
the Threshold is less agressive and affects much more softly other colors which
in turn gives the apperance of a shift in color (less saturated). In Gimp this
effect can also be seen but to a lesser extent since the threshold is much more
contrasted, in fact its in Krita it is not possible to adjust the threshold to
affect the colors in the same way as the gimp.

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are watching all bug changes.

Reply via email to