On 11/4/14 1:43 AM, Matija Grabnar wrote:
OK, now I see that we come from fundamentally opposite viewpoints.

I'm arguing about what measures it makes sense to use to get good
protection while still enabling people to use their residential internet
for more than just consumption, while you are determined to block all
email originating from residential addresses, regardless of validity or
how well the servers are run.

Right-o! :) You see, the problem is that even if a tiny percentage of mail is originating from well-run servers in consumer space, the overwhelming majority of it is spam, primarily from infected hosts. So never mind rDNS (which is a very cheap and useful initial test to perform), most ISPs publish indexes of their residential space to allow the larger mail providers to blacklist that space up front.

Since our goals are exactly opposite, I don't think we'll ever see
eye-to-eye on what steps are appropriate.

It's fine for you not to agree, as long as you understand the landscape. :) Several others have already given you the excellent advice to get a cheap VPS and do your thing(s) on a network that is well supported for those things. If you're interested I'm sure we can find you some solid recommendations. Make sure that you find out in advance what address space you'll be on. That way you can check the reputation lists in advance. It would suck to get on a new system only to find that still can't send mail.

Good luck,

Doug

Reply via email to